Newbie
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| chkflip
|
Mafia Rolecop
|
Started
|
Survived
|
Scum win
|
| My first game. The Acting Method was my scum partner and the IC. Several of the "newbies" were experienced players, notably serrapaladin. I didn't start the game intending to act newbish, but when other players assumed I was relatively inxperienced I didn't correct them, though I did make reference to games on other sites. Town had some bad luck in the form of a Doctor who got many players' backs up on day 1, wound up the lynch leader, and refused to claim. I noticed his PR tells early on, and tried to get a credible alternative wagon on another townie so that when Luisss did eventually claim there would be a place for the votes to go. Instead, he was lynched and my day 1 alternative bandwagon was the day 2 lynch. Then, the game got serious. The jailkeeper, CityElectric, blocked me on night 2 so there was no kill. Fortunately she thought it was possible that she had protected the intended victim and didn't claim or breadcrumb. We killed her on night 3 and sailed to the win on day 4 when one townie voted another. It was a fun game, but really stressful drawing scum in my first MS game. A family member passed away during the game, too, which meant that I wasn't much of a presence on day 2 until the day was nearly done. I didn't start another game until this one ended, in part because I didn't want to blow my not-so-experienced cover. The game was a lot of fun and I've been happy to see that several of the players are still on site and playing games.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| TraceyLyn11
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Killed Night 4
|
Scum win
|
| This was my second Newbie game. GoodMorning was the IC, and this was our first game together. Day 1 was a long struggle due to several replace-outs and at least one extension so that a last minute replacement would have time to read the game. Three key replacements were VisceraEyes and Ineffective who placed into strongly suspected slots, and GuyInFreezer, who was the Mafia Goon but had inherited a slot that was not under much suspicion. Unshakeable town reads were developed, but many mistakes were made and the game was ultimately won by GIF and Mac. My key takeaways were: just because you know a player is town doesn't mean you want them around at endgame, and no lynch at MYLO should not be considered if you have confirmed town or universally recognized town. We would have won this game if I had objected to no lynch and gone after the player I thought was scum.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| borkjerfkin
|
Vanilla Town
|
Day 1 Page 10
|
Survived
|
Town win
|
| This was my first replacement game. It was memorable because it was my game playing with Ineffective and [[AngryPidgeon}} who was the IC. My slot was under suspicion when I replaced in, and I was able to turn that around pretty quickly based on my catch up posts and scum list. I picked out 3 players as scummy, PoEed that down to two and then voted the player who was actually scum. This game was plagued by replacements, including the player I had scum-read and we wound up not killing him until Day 2. Between role claims and a jailkeep after one scum was lynched, AngryPidgeon and I were the most credible alternatives for scum. I waffled, invented scenarios and generally dragged my feet for at least a week before AngryPidgeon was lynched and town won. I still need to work on being more decisive and less paranoid.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| DeasVail
|
Vanilla Town
|
Day 1 Page 15
|
Survived
|
Town win
|
| This was my second replacement game. I replaced in on page 15 of day 1. The day 1 bandwagons were a quandary because the two main wagons were both scum. I wound up hammering at just before 3 am my time. The second scum was jailkept that night and lynched on day 2, making this a perfect town win. It was a great player list, and I particularly enjoyed meeting FearThePoster and BROseidon. This was the first game where I went into detail about my idiosyncratic meaning for "trajectory" in mafia.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| RachMarie, Malakittens
|
Vanilla Town
|
Replaced in Day 4 3P LYLO
|
Survived
|
Town win
|
| I replaced into a 3P LYLO with Ms Marangal and Majiffy. My slot was confirmed town because my predecessor hadn't hammered. Sorting out which of Majiffy and Mara were scum and town was a challenge. Meta, personal experience, and the thread itself all pointed vaguely in the direction of Mara. And so it was.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Messiah, Zaicon
|
Vanilla Town
|
Replaced in Night 1 Page 18
|
Survived
|
Town win
|
| This is the first time that I've replaced in to a slot that was being strongly scum-read. I read the ISO before sending the replacement volunteer PM and didn't see anything objectively scummy. Then I read the thread start to finish and knew I was a potential day 2 mislynch. I got past that on day 2, but it looked like I could become a mislynch at endgame instead. I should have stuck with my day 1 reads on day 3 because I was right.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Nobody Special
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Endgamed
|
Scum Win
|
| IC, and not such an auspicious first IC game. The team consisted of JasonWazza and Lynx. My play was unspectacular enough to result in 2 days worth of severe tunneling by worthy town players.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| RachMarie, Nobody Special
|
Mafia Goon
|
Replaced in on day 2
|
Survived
|
Scum Win
|
| This is the first game I've replaced into as scum. Thor was my team mate. The town team had some extreme confirmation bias going on, and this turned out to be a fairly easy scum win.
|
Micro
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| AngryPidgeon
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Day 1 Lynch (self hammered)
|
Town Win
|
| This was my first MS game with buldermar and Syryana, and my second with orcinus_theoriginal. There were other players of note as well. For me, this was a terrible game. It was the first time at MS I had a strong town read on a player on page 1. Saying that on page 1 was a terrible idea, and it got worse from there. buldermar was scum and did a great job of taking advantage of the paranoia I sowed, and I did a terrible job of sticking with my reads. Eventually, I self-hammered. Something I'm not likely to do again any time soon. This game was where the idea for the Selkies hydra was born. And town won. The scum team was buldermar and pitoli. AngryPidgeon is a fantastic mod. I look for his games in sign-ups.
|
borkgame as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| borkjerfkin
|
Town Innocent Child
|
Started
|
Survived
|
Town Win
|
| This was the first game where orcinus and I played as Selkies. It was also the first game where I saw a semi-effective town block form. orcinus came up with the strategy of fake-claiming PGO to hopefully prevent our being the night 1 kill. It worked. But, it was not the last town lie of the game. ArcAngel9 also lied about her doctor role, saying she was a one-shot bodyguard. She didn't believe our claim, so protected us on night 2. Scum didn't believe our claim either. We went through 2 days without lynching scum, and then town got its act together. Arcangel9 protected us again on night 2 and from there it was an autowin situation. Majiffy was lynched on day 3 and Jennifer on day 4. It was a tense and at times contentious game for town, but in the end things came together.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| AngryPidgeon
|
3rd Party (Assassin)
|
Started
|
Night 1 assassin & mafia kill
|
Town Win
|
| I lost this game when I selected two night actions from a list. I should have chosen a night kill instead of 2 investigative roles. I plugged along and helped town to a win with my day 1 play. On night 1, I watched/tracked the last scum player and saw him visit me. And then I died. :D It was another great group of players. The micro queue attracts really good mafiascum players. The scum team was Majiffy and Mac.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| N
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Endgamed
|
Scum Win
|
| This was our first game as ². The scum team of Mr E Roll and Red Coyote played well.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| chkflip
|
Town Miller Fisherman
|
Started
|
Survived
|
Town Win
|
| This started as a difficult game due to not knowing any of the players besides bacde. I decided not to claim miler on the offhand chance that I'd get a useful one-shot via fishing. Vegito (Majiffy/Nacho hydra) replaced in and the game turned funny, though they were in the lynch lead for much of the game. Another replacement, mrbungle had a key role. At the end of the day, we ran up several players to L-1, forced nearly every PR to claim, and finally lynched scum. That night, Vegito tracked the final scum to his kill. We argued a bit, decided to wait for the scum player to post, then mrbungle took matters into his own hands and executed Beliasaurus. Perfect town win. The scum team was Ghostlin and Beliasaurus
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| RachMarie
|
Town Odd Night Shaman (Doc)
|
Started
|
Killed by Mafia Night 1
|
Town Win
|
| We lynched scum on day 1, but were erroneously deathtunneling the Nero Cain/Ms Marangal hydra, Sugar Cain. Just as well we died night 1.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| jake from state farm
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Replaced out
|
Town Win
|
| Replaced out on day 1 due to a personal conflict with the moderator. Not included in win/loss statistics.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| angrypidgeon
|
Town Cop
|
Started
|
Killed by Mafia Night 1
|
Town Win
|
| The set up was 5 vanilla town, 2 millers, cop and role cop for town, and godfather and goon for scum. Though the set-up was a little townsided, town dominated this game due to the players being so familiar with each other. By page 2 a town core of 3 had formed, and by page 8 the core had 5 members, most of whom were agreed (and correct) about the identity of the scum team. It was a bit of a struggle to get from there to a lynch. Perfect town win. We lynched the godfather on day 1, and viewed the final scum on night 1 but didn't live to tell the tale. The scum team was mastin2 and nachomamma8
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| CheeryDog
|
Vengeful Townie
|
Started
|
Survived
|
Town Win
|
| This was the first Rift Adrift game. The 9p vengeball format was great. This was the first nightless game I actually enjoyed playing.
|
Open
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| TraceyLyn11
|
Town Lover
|
Started
|
Endgamed
|
Scum win
|
| This was my third game on-site and my first with orcinu_theoriginal, Ms Marangal and Klick. My lover replaced out and was replaced by Svenskt Stål. It was a fun game, and ultimately Town lost. The scum team was Ms Marangal, leviathan93, Voodoo Lady and Nekoko.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Zaicon
|
Vanilla Town
|
Started
|
Endgamed
|
SK win
|
| A very bad town game on my part. By the final day that town could win (which we didn't know due to night kills not being flipped), I felt I had no credibility to set a lynch direction, so all I could really do was dig my heels in over what I (correctly) thought was a mislynch. The next day, it 1-1-1. I picked the mafia player to hammer and the SK won. The scum team was Malakittens and Goodmorning. The SK was bulbazac
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Sanjay
|
Mafia goon
|
Started
|
Day 2 shot
|
Town win
|
| This setup has been discontinued due to being excessively townsided. Even so, my play was lackluster. Still, a fun game in many ways.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Ms Marangal
|
Mafia goon
|
Started
|
Survived
|
Scum win
|
| GiF's awesome night kill choices won this game.]
|
an="6" | This setup has been discontinued due to being excessively townsided. Even so, my play was lackluster. Still, a fun game in many ways.
|}
Mini Themed
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Cephrir
|
Town Ability Cop, etc
|
Started
|
Killed by scum night 3
|
Scum win
|
| Pretty much shellacked by GoodCop_BadCop and Ms Marangal. And people wonder why I'm so paranoid
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| AurorusVox
|
|
Started
|
|
| In Progress
|
Large Normal
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| mastin2
|
|
Replaced in on Night 1
|
|
| In progress. Replaced in as hydra after half of Beauty and the Beast was force-replaced.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| PeregrineV
|
|
Started
|
|
| In progress
|
Large Themed
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| T-Bone
|
Day 1 - Rolestopper
|
Started
|
Killed by scum Night 1
|
Scum win
|
| Setup was fascinating. This was my first game after my initial Newbie, and marked my stepping out into the larger MS community. My play wasn't too bad, but I should have tried harder to get one of my scum reads lynched.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| borkjerfkin
|
Red Scum Ability Cop
|
Started
|
Lynched Day 1
|
Blue scum win
|
| I didn't get to play for long, but the game was also a lot of fun to watch. GuyInFreezer played a hell of a Red Scum game, as did TiphaineDeath. BROseidon pulled out a Blue scum win with Orcinus and RachMarie.
|
|
|
| Modded by
|
Role
|
Entry
|
Status
|
Outcome
|
| Vi
|
Vanilla town
|
Started
|
endgamed
|
Scum win
|
| Probably my worst town performance ever. It will take a while to process all the lessons that should be learned from this one. The playerlist was amazing, though, and this was a first game with several players with whom I hope to play many more games.
|
