| Game
|
Role
|
Status
|
Comments
|
| NG 797 |
Vanilla Townie - Lynched D2 |
Mafia Win |
A very interesting game for my first attempt at mafia. It was a bit of a fiasco on my part (I ended up being the first person to be lynched, and while I managed to stumble my way onto the scumteam in a roundabout way during Day 2, I messed up determining who the scumteam was by trying to make connections when I really didn't know what to look for, which ultimately left me clueless on actual scum. I also was so confident after making my first wallpost that I asked for doctor protection, which led to another fiasco of its own. Whoops.), but ultimately, it was a fantastic first learning experience. Alex (the scum I butted heads with for the majority of the game) ended up being an older player (Haylen), which made me feel a little better about the loss, but also gave me a rival, but a sour loss is a sour loss and it's one of those things you end up remembering for a long time.
|
| NG 836 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win |
My first win, but I didn't really deserve it. This game taught me a lot of things about how to get lynches pushed through, why claiming and being clear about your claim is a good thing, and why tunneling is a terrible, terrible thing (although I wouldn't learn this lesson for a very long time). This was one of those games with a very intense D1 with a bunch of crazy shit happening, and then after the first mislynch, the game gets pretty clear. I also built up some cool town synergy with Chinaman in this one, which was pretty cool, but we ended up turning on each other pretty intensely after the final scum was hammered. Which shows it always pays never to give up until the moderator flips everyone, even if it is only for drawing out amusing reactions.
|
| NG 826 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win |
Ah, now this was a win I deserved! I replaced in late-game, which gave me a bit of advantage, and then promptly started pushing to lynch the cop with a guilty on the last scum. I succeeded, and she never outed her result. Next day, in 3 player LyLo, I attacked both players pretty hard, and ended up voting the scum. The townie read over the cop's posts, figured out that she was trying to breadcrumb a guilty on the scum, and hammered. Fun, clean game, and mad props to RPG Twilight for surviving as long as he did in that one.
|
| NG 856 |
Vanilla Townie - Lynched D1 |
Town Win |
A game with mixed memories, this one. It was the first game where my strong angry tunneling self attached onto scum, but it didn't exactly turn out too well for me. The town was a bit... inactive, with flakers galore (mod + IC included). The IC ended up tunneling pretty hard on me day 1, which I thought I defended pretty well against, but it wasn't enough and I ended up being deadline lynched, which wasn't so bad, I guess. This ended up being a pretty long newbie game on record, mostly because of Ythan's insane posting (563 posts, my god). It was his first newbie game and he pulled scum, and it was a pretty impressive performance; but it was also Thor's first newbie game, and he was a pretty big threat that survived until LyLo and ended up winning it. Soylent's endgame flavor was pretty chuckleworthy, but I have to be honest I know nothing of the middle of this game because it was so damn long and I was a skimmer back then.
|
| NG 848 |
Vanilla Townie - Night Killed Night 5 |
Mafia Win |
This game was a HUGE turning point for me as a player, I think. It was the first time I was nightkilled, which felt good even though it was very late in the game, but it was also an awesome game. I was playing pretty poorly early in the game, but after Haylen spared me from a Day 1 lynch, I stepped it up a bit. The next day, two major wagons formed; one on sposh, and one on Haylen. I defended Haylen like hell, got a sposh lynch, but he flipped scum. Then there was a no lynch/no kill game played around by the scum a little until I drove through a lynch on Jase/SaintKerrigan scum which ended up getting me killed over the night. Then a different townie was lynched because his connections to lynched scum looked fishy as hell, but it's a loss to VRK and that's not exactly something to be ashamed of. One of my favorite games of all time, though. It was hard fought, and hard lost.
|
| NG 869 |
Vanilla Townie - Endgamed |
Mafia Win |
Pretty cool game, got to play with some awesome players (Ellibereth, Zorblag, and Pulindar). Elli and SensFan ended up being scum with SensFan and Elli pulling a fake cop claim to fake counterclaim gambit that was interesting. I picked up on the bullshit decently quickly after Elli died, but I had a lot of trouble convincing everyone else that I wasn't just tunneling. LyLo came down to Zorblag, Pul, and I, with Zorblag and I cross-voting and Pul holding the hammer vote. It was a hell of a fight, but Pulindar ended up not getting the hammer down in time. It was on the right person though, so I take a tiny bit of solace in that.
|
| NG 911 |
Vanilla Townie - Endgamed |
Mafia Win |
Another sour loss, although we sort of got steamrolled in this one. I ended up with some classic double-tunneling on two townies day 2, managing to get one of them lynched, while the other one was nightkilled. The next day, scum came out with a guilty on me, which turned into kind of a shitshow. I attacked him for claiming an innocent read on someone he was attacking for most of the day, and one of the other townies agreed with me, held back his vote while he looked for a partner. Meanwhile, the other townie voted another townie, one of the scum flaked, and we had to wait very long for Zach to replace in and coordinate a quickhammer with his partner. Argh.
|
| NG 922 |
Vanilla Townie - Lynched D3 |
Mafia Win |
Last game when I said we got steamrolled was also a bit inaccurate. This game we were utterly destroyed. Scumteam was Furry and Acosmist, we outed our doctor Day 1, I lurked hard, Elli lurked hard, and the game ended on a no-lynch. Ouch. It's a painful game to talk about, but it's a good lesson to make sure that someone you trust is leading the town and not to let the town get apathetic; if you are lurking in a lagging game as town and you don't feel like getting it started, replace out and get someone who can in the slot. Many things kill a town, but apathy is the worst of all of the evils.
|
| NG 934 |
Doctor - Night Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win |
My first game as an IC, I think? It's pretty entertaining comparing my style of then to my style of now, though; back then, I was polite, didn't post often, relied mainly on walls to get my point across, used a big ol' IC post to introduce, and actually put up with that RQS bullshit. How the times have changed... Anyways, this was a "get killed Night 1, scum rolls town" kind of game, but it's not like I would have changed the outcome of the game at all. The closest I got to finding scum was having the weaker member of my team third on my scumlist, which might have resulted in a weak push much, much later in the game, but Deer's play was superb and I doubt I would have gotten anywhere near catching him as scum. I think this was also my first time being killed Night 1, and that felt pretty damn good.
|
| NG 940 |
Mafia Roleblocker - Survived |
Mafia Win |
Excellent game, this one. It was my first time rolling scum, and I got it with Nobody Special, who was a pretty great partner. It started out as a pretty conventional game, though. Lynch the easy mislynch day 1, buddy up with someone and let two townies who are having some conflicts battle it out before swooping in for a late vote, then fake a cop guilty on a townie in LyLo. But Equinox ended up putting up a hell of a fight, confirmed my partner as scum somehow someway, then took us to 3 player LyLo with Thor as the deciding vote. It was extraordinarily intense, with us getting dragged into a wall war which ultimately ended up as us throwing literally everything we could possibly think of at each other but still manage to keep going, somehow... But in the end, Thor chose Equinox, not me, and that felt good. Another one of my favorite games. AurorusVox's first newbie game, but I killed that man before he had a chance to do shit because Lemon can be scary.
|
| NG 970 |
Vanilla Townie - Lynched D3 |
Mafia Win |
Not my best game. Hell, not even close to a good game for me. I ended up lurking far too much, while pushing lynches on ALL TOWN and defending the only scum who managed to get lynched (thanks to Shotty's intervention) pretty damn hard, which ended up being my demise the next day, leaving scum to win pretty handily. I also let paranoia guide me pretty hard this game, which was not good not good. Not a game that I like to remember, but the lesson was learned.
|
| NG 1011 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win |
MOOOSE! This game was pretty awesome. I lurked hard in the beginning, which was bad, but in LyLo I finally got my shit together and found the scumteam after one of them self-destructed a bit. I got one lynched the first day of LyLo, and on the second, we ended up crossvoting almost immediately, leaving the hammer to moose. He sent us through a hell of a ride, threatening to hammer me when he was sober almost as soon as LyLo begun and then being steadily convinced the other way until he hammered for the town win. Very enjoyable game.
|
| NG 1024 |
Mafia Goon - Survived |
Mafia Win |
Crazy game, this one. One of those wins you don't deserve, this one. Mastin and I ended up being scumpartners, and it was a rough uphill battle for the majority of the way. I hadn't much experience with mafia at this point and wasn't quite comfortable with reacting to things when my scumplans went awry, and pulled off some shitty terrible distancing with Mastin, and he didn't lynch me on a crucial day and we basically ended up becoming lovers, which was not fun. We also had our kill stopped twice (twice!) before we managed to lynch him thanks to DLG replacing in later in the game. LyLo was not so bad compared to the rest of the game, but it was a hell of a game that I enjoyed very much. It was also my first time playing with Mastin, who ended up being a player that would help my play improve by leaps and bounds and bounds and bounds. Plus, DLG. Damn.
|
| NG 1025 |
Vanilla Townie - Lynched Day 4 |
Mafia Win |
This game taught me some LESSONS, man. I had defended the scum who got lynched Day 1 incredibly incredibly hard because it seemed like every thought process I was having during my catchup he was having as well, and so I defended him until he died, and I wasn't able to make it past that for a long, long time. Since that messup, I was somehow avoided being lynched until LyLo, where I finally managed to figure out who was scum, but it was too little, too late. Definitely don't blame DLG for hammering me there; Neil's play in this game was fantastic even though we let him get away with a bit of lurking.
|
| NG 1030 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 3 |
Mafia Win |
Another case of scum playing well and me being left in the darkest of the darkest darkness about it. I tried of a bit of a different playstyle that I liked although it is completely different to my current playstyle, but it was interesting. I called a townread of the day whenever the hell I felt like it; hilariously enough, my first one was wrong :P. I got her partner pretty quickly, though, after the townies decided they weren't going to lynch anymore townreads of mine, but I got killed before I could realize oh my god Purple Orange is actually scum.
|
| NG 1033 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win |
All hail the Amished Tell. I had played another game with Amished where the famous thing first came into use, but this game is the greatest example of it. Another townie picked up on the Goon's scumminess and gotten him lynched while I was pushing the other scum pretty hard, then the other scum got replaced and drops the Amish tell. I didn't really have that much faith in it, but then the guy gets replaced and his new replacement drops that shit again and I'm like "okay, you're done. either you're scum or I'm scum, die.". And he flipped scum. Now, I have a modified version that I keep in my pocket since it's gotten so warped lately, but it's still proven accurate as fuck to this day. The only tell I will ever trust, <3 and miss Amished :(
|
| NG 1035 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 1 |
Town Win |
Pretty good game for me. I replaced into this game without any IC cares or whatever, and decided just to play. Pegged a scum that replaced out, which took the wind out of my sails a bit, but attacked the cop enough where I was killed over him, which is a VT's number one job. The scum I pegged died the next day, and town cleaned up after that. This game is the reason why you shouldn't really avoid nightkills; sometimes, it's just what the game needs for a town win, even if your reads are still pretty good.
|
| NG 1041 |
Cop - Killed Night 2 |
Mafia Win |
I tried outing myself early so my investigation didn't go to waste; it wasn't the best of moves. Personal interaction is still a HUGE part of finding scum, and confirming yourself takes that opportunity away, it takes away the possibility for scum to be stupid and not kill you, it ruins so many things and I will never pull crap like that again, probably. I did manage to confirm moose as town with a cop investigation and aaah through a bit of a ridiculous gambit (chocolate and strawberry townies, lol), which SHOULD have given town a better chance, but Escho acted quickly and aaah was impulsive, and so town didn't pull this one through :(. Decently impressed with my game here though, despite all of the fuckups.
|
| NG 1047 |
Mafia Goon - Lynched Day 4 |
Mafia Win |
AAAAAH THIS GAME WAS SO FUCKED SO UTTERLY UTTERLY FUCKED. AGH. Every single slot was replaced except for one (and it wasn't the mod's), and I ended up replacing in late game with everything going to shit. And I don't like replacing into scum slots when the town is apathetic because it feels like nothing really matters and you're just sitting there waiting for the town to drop the guillotine on itself and even when you do win it doesn't matter because the game was a hell hole of hell. Glass was a great mafia partner, though. Game was just stupid and bad. Argh.
|
| NG 1052 |
Cop - Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win |
I didn't live long, but this was a good game. One of the newbies got a bit eager and tried hammering a bit prematurely in a way that was fucking town as fuck even though it was on my top suspect at the time, but then I managed to turn things around a bit and get Stels lynched as scum, which felt good. Sundy pulled out an impressive win in the end, but we made him work long and hard for that one. It was a shame I was a power role, but the 1 v 1 trade was worth it. This game left me pretty convinced that I couldn't play on top of my game unless I played normally even when I got a power role, and overall, was pretty happy about it.
|
| NG 1070 |
Mafia Goon - Survived |
Mafia Win |
We gave town the business in this one, which is always nice. Elyssa was an extremely gifted scumpartner, and we coasted through the first couple of days pretty easily. Splitfarvle pulled a damn good desperation measure out of nowhere in LyLo which floored the hell out of us, but our play was strong enough in the past and he made *just the right amount* of mistakes for us to pull the win through. It was crazy scary to have the game wrapped up and then out pops a cop that has innocents on every townie alive, though. Crazy, crazy scary; I haven't seen anyone pull that off since.
|
| NG 1074 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win |
Hoppster collected himself a nice win in this one. I don't really think anyone knew what the hell was going on in this one, which happens sometimes. I was impressed by Pine's first showing as a newbie, though. Aggressive as hell and somehow managed to throw out gambits that didn't fuck everything over... impressive. Ended up being a pretty classic game, though, with scum doing exactly what scum had to do and getting a win as a result.
|
| NG 1079 |
Mafia Roleblocker - Lynched Day 2 |
Mafia Win |
So, in the beginning of this game when Grey and I saw we both flipped scum, we sort of chuckled to ourselves and looked forward to the easy scum sweep. Then Herodotus happened. I got pegged to the wall in this game Day 1, fought like hell to push an EASY MISLYNCH through, and then decided not to kill him during the night because we knew he was VT and we wanted to look for power roles elsewhere and we were afraid of doctor protect, and my god was that a mistake. Next day, he didn't let up, and I fought like hell and like hell, but he got me in the end. Made Grey's job a hell of a lot harder, but he pulled it through in the end because he's damn good scum playr and the cards were stacked against town from the beginning. But this game taught me a valuable lesson: when someone needs to die, kill them. Period. A blocked kill is a blocked kill, sure, but the town doesn't get an extra lynch even if you fuck up and doctor protects successfully. So don't let him live because of fear. Kill him.
|
| NG 1090 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win |
Frustrating game. I correctly read someone as town that Jason was convinced was scum, managed to peg one scum, and defended the townie as hard as I possibly could from getting lynched. He got lynched anyways. Scum killed me. Scum won. Bah.
|
| NG 1119 |
Mafia Rolecop - Lynched Day 3 |
Town Win |
First loss as mafia in a newbie game, and it was all due to some impressive, impressive play by the newbies. I didn't really make any significant mistakes, escept for maybe bussing my partner a bit prematurely. Played this one classically, killed one threat (zMuffin) and buddied the hell out of the other one (Hikari Link), which got pretty much everyone to view me as town when we made it into LyLo thanks to Junpei getting himself modkilled. The last day came down to a MyLo situation with me claiming jailkeeper in order to bait a counterclaim from Ree, who I knew was the jailkeeper thanks to my rolecop result. I was pretty confident I had the game in the bag, to be honest, and I almost had Ree hammered many times. But in the end, smargaret hammered me and town handed me my first newbie game mafia loss. Another one of my favorite games, mostly because of some stellar newbie performances. Ended up marking my taking a little break from mafia.
|
| NG 1234 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1232 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1239 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1242 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 2 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1238 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1221 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1243 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 2 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1229 |
Jailkeeper - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1230 |
Mafia Goon - Lynched Day 1 |
Town Win
|
| NG 1255 |
Mafia Goon - Lynched Day 1 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1273 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 2 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1264 |
Vanilla Townie - Endgamed |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1271 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1270 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1282 |
Jailkeeper - Endgamed |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1281 |
Vanilla Townie - Killed Night 2 |
Town Win
|
| NG 1272 |
Mafia Goon - Survived |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1294 |
Town Cop - Killed Night 1 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1301v1 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Abandoned
|
| NG 1285 |
Vanilla Townie - Survived |
Town Win
|
| NG 1287 |
Vanilla Tonwie - Killed Night 3 |
Mafia Win
|
| NG 1293 |
Town Cop - Survived |
Town Win
|
