| Game |
Mod |
Role |
Status |
Result |
Notes
|
| Newbie 321: Contact with the Mob |
Mr. Flay |
Townie |
Lynched D3 |
Mafia Win |
|
| A very good game for a Newbie, with Zindaras (scum) winning the trust of Mr Stoofer (doctor) by not NKing him after outing him during twilight on Day 1, then getting townies lynched on Days 2 and 3 despite scummy play on Day 1. Lesson learned: being right is no use if you can't persuade people to believe you.
|
| Mini 423: Calvin & Hobbes |
Mr Stoofer |
Hobbes' Tuna Sandwich (Townie) |
Eaten N2 |
Mafia Win |
Replaced remussaidow Day 1
|
| A hidden mountainous game (2 scum, 10 vanilla townies), in which one of the scum (EmpTyger) was lynched Day 1, leaving VitaminR to play the majority of the game as the lone scum, pulling out an impressive win. This was my second game on Mafiascum, and contained a number of the site's more accomplished players, making it an excellent accelerated learning tool. My own play wasn't terrific, though I take some solace in having VitR in my top 3 suspects before being killed Night 2.
|
| Open 22: Roleblocker C9 |
Patrick |
Townie |
Endgamed D3 |
Mafia Win |
Replaced beanbagboy Day 2
|
| Replaced in LyLo after the town's only power role, a roleblocker, was lynched D1. Found one scum, but guessed wrong on a tossup between an active player with circumstantial scumtells and a lurker on Day 3 (it was the lurker). Every player still alive on Day 2 was eventually replaced - the second scum made it to Day 3 with only three posts for the entire game. Not the result that this setup deserved.
|
| Mini 431: Happy Normal Mafia |
HurriKaty |
Townie |
Alive D2 |
Abandoned |
|
| Game killed Day 2 due to Metatron (the Godfather) outing himself and the other two scum in the thread after he was bussed to a deadline lynch by his buddies.
|
| Newbie 397 |
Glork |
Cop |
Survived |
Town Win! |
|
| My first winning result on Mafiascum, which I almost screwed up on Day 2 by putting a townie at lynch -1, only switching my vote to one of the scum after LoudmouthLee (the doctor) yelled at me. He protected me Night 2, allowing me to find the second scum and finish things from there. A very valuable learning experience.
|
| Assassins in the Palace |
Kelly Chen |
King |
Survived |
Palace (Town) Win! |
|
| Something a bit different. This game was nightless and had 2 kings, 2 assassins and 10 guards (townies), with the assassins trying to kill the kings and the guards trying to protect them. Each time an assassin was lynched they had an opportunity to make one or two vig-style kill(s). Turned into a bit of a wagon-fest, then a crapshoot at the end, and I was lucky that the last assassin killed the other king but missed me. An interesting experiment, but probably not a viable format unless all of the townies are on the same page strategy-wise.
|
| Open 33: Crush Mafia |
Rand Althor |
Mafia Goon |
Survived |
Mafia Win! |
|
| A C9 game with a lyncher, lynchee and vengeful-style Godfather. I was scum with somestrangeflea, who was the GF. Plagued by inactivity for most of the first day, leading to a dubious deadline lynch of a player with only two votes. We killed JDodge (the lyncher) Night 1, leaving the way clear for a quicklynch when a townie voted first on Day 2. JDodge really likes to be reminded of this game. My first game as scum on Mafiascum.
|
| Mini 470: Some Guys Are Trying To Kill You |
Maz Medias |
Townie |
Endgamed D5 |
Mafia Win |
Winner of 'Most Enjoyable Mini' in 2007 Scummies
|
| Quite the up and down game - we were in LyLo by Day 2 with the cop and vig dead, and it appeared we'd need to lynch correctly three times in a row to win. We came back to lynch scum on the next two days and the doctor got a successful protect on Night 3. This left us with 5 players, one of which was a confirmed mason and one of which was scum. Thinking we would be in a strong position on Day 5, we gave the claimed doctor the benefit of the doubt and lynched the next suspect in line, who turned out to be a townie. As expected, the scum killed the doctor on Night 4 and we were left with three players, one of whom was confirmed town. Unfortunately, it turned out that the last remaining scum had a daykill power...
|
| Mini 454: Candy Mafia |
ShadowLurker |
Tootsie Rolls (Townie) |
Killed N4 |
RRSC Mafia Win |
|
| An interesting setup with two two-player scumgroups, none of whom knew who their partners were at the start of the game. Unfortunately, two mislynches and four townie nightkills left the town in a practically unwinnable position on Day 3, and the rest of the game was a runoff between the two groups of scum. Enjoyable for the first two days, though I felt like the collective scum and some misleading flavour had too much influence over the town's chances of winning. I was just happy that Stewie caught on to what was happening and didn't lynch me on the last day.
|
| Mini 493: Methodical Mafia |
Mr Stoofer |
Mafia |
Lynched D4 |
Town Win |
|
| An experimental game in which all players with power roles submitted an ordered list of night actions prior to day 1, and were bound by this for the remainder of the game. I came disturbingly close to being Glorked at deadline on day 1, and had to scramble like crazy to hang on. One of my buddies went down to the SK on night 1, then the other was lynched day 2 due to an unlucky break on his claim. I managed to get the SK lynched on day 3, but I was targeted by two cops and a roleblocker that night, so it was curtains for me the following day. Not a bad game overall, though I wasn't super-happy with my play.
|
| BM's Mystery Mafia |
Battle Mage |
Canada (Doctor) |
Killed N2 |
Evil Leaders Mafia Win |
|
| I tried not to be afraid of scumhunting as the doc - turned out that I was right about the first two people I went after being scumbuddies, and I got nightkilled early as a result. Fun while it lasted, I was unhappy that I died when I did. Endgame came down to two scum from different groups plus a townie who was left to choose between them - apparently there's an alternate ending still to come.
|
| Mini 450: Evil Genius Mafia |
Zindaras |
The Great Mesmero (Doctor) |
Killed N3 |
Super Agents (Mafia) Win |
Replaced Keyboard Fox Day 1
|
| A fun game overall, the town was a bit hit and miss but we were doing OK until Day 3, at which point we misguessed the setup and shot ourselves in the foot quite severely, making the game more or less unwinnable on Day 4. I made the mistake of falling in love with a wacky setup theory and claimed Doctor prematurely, thinking I might have actually been a cult recruiter. I was wrong, and after spearheading the lynch of the townie that I believed I had culted I was unsurprisingly killed that night.
|
| Open 51: Texas Justice Mafia |
FeRnAnDo |
Mafia |
Killed N1 |
Town Win |
|
| As usual for this setup, this was a pretty wild game. I thought I was doing fine, but Oman killed me basically for kicks on Night 1, and the mass carnage ended in a town win on Day 3.
|
| Mini 504: PEGBAM Mafia |
pickemgenius/Flameaxe |
Townie |
Killed N3 |
Mafia Win |
Replaced poppinpuffin Day 2
|
| Basically a guest appearance, as I replaced in at the end of day 2 and was nightkilled after a pretty quick day 3. Karen's townie self-hammer on day 3 really killed the town's chances in this game.
|
| Stargate SG-1 Mafia |
ChannelDelibird/Battle Mage |
Sgt. Siler (Townie), Bill Lee (Townie) |
Killed N2, N7 |
Replicators (Mafia) Win |
NKed Night 2, then replaced DeanWinchester Day 3 and was NKed again Night 7
|
| This was a very fun game, which nearly died when the original mod disappeared, but was miraculously resurrected by Battle Mage and played through to completion. The town did really well as a whole, lynching scum 6 times in 8 attempts (including 5 straight at one point), but was eventually overcome by the last remaining scum after a mislynch on Day 10. Noteworthy as the game in which I missed not one, but two scum fakeclaiming my flavour.
|
| Mafia 70: Traditional Mafia |
Patrick |
Doctor |
Killed N2 |
Mafia Win |
|
| Another early death - town was doing fairly well in the early going, but lost its way after lynching the two more obvious scum.
|
| Food Fight Mafia |
DrippingGoofball |
Linus Smart (Cop) |
Killed N2 |
Serial Killer Wins |
|
| I died early with an inncoent result on the Serial Killer (who eventually won). Didn't get much done in this game.
|
| Mini 427: Clue Mafia 2 |
Mastermind of Sin |
Professor Plum (Townie) |
Killed N3 |
Mafia Win |
Replaced Jack Day 3
|
| A fine example of how to be a shitty lurker.
|
| Doctor Who Mafia 2 |
Battle Mage |
Harriet Jones (Town Vote Giver) |
Survived |
Town Win! |
|
| The town dominated this one, with 9 town survivors in a 30 player game. This was a pretty fast game too, with 12 deaths by the start of Day 2 and the whole thing wrapped up by Day 5. A lot of luck and some decent sleuthing, along with an extremely unlucky scum fakeclaim (Yosarian2 claimed the flavour of the only other unclaimed player) left this one in little doubt. I hadn't survived a game for a while, so this win made me very happy.
|
| Open 35: Big Love Mafia |
Lawrencelot |
Townie |
Endgamed N5 |
Mafia Win |
|
| Ugh. 5 mislynches in a row, scum wins without losing a single goon. I got lost at the start of this game due to the massive amount of content generated in the first week, and never really caught up. I was surprised to find out after the game that I'd actually picked the scum, but I never really pushed them (with one exception) because I wasn't confident enough in my reads. Just ugh.
|
| PIRATES v NINJAS! |
Mr Stoofer |
Michael Dudikoff (Ninja) |
Killed D3 |
Town Win |
|
| Scumhunted too well for my own good on day 1, forcing a tracker claim from Guardian, who was goblin scum. His group tried to kill me night 1, thus discovering that I was scum, so he outed me as he was being speedlynched on day 2 and I was dayvigged the next day. Short but eventful, as we also managed to nightkill another of the opposing scum during my two days in the game. Fun while it lasted for me, but it turned into a numbers game at the end and was won by the town despite superior scum numbers overall.
|
| House Mafia |
Albert B. Rampage/Claus |
Good Doctor |
Killed D4 |
Bad Doctors Win |
|
| Good, fun game - there was a different mechanic in play each day, ranging from a double lynch to electing a one-shot cop. Town was doing well, getting this game to a 5/1 split on day 4. Unfortunately, the day 4 twist was that each townie got a free daykill, which triggered a mass meltdown, ending in a scum win after the remaining townies killed each other. shaft.ed did really well to win this one for the scum after his buddies got taken out early on.
|
| Mini 545: The Final Stand |
death_omen |
Cop (75% accurate) |
Killed N3 |
Town Win! |
Replaced Death's Door D1
|
| We lynched the Godfather day 2, then I investigated shaka!! (a goon) that night. This could have put the town in a very good position, except that I got a bad dice roll and thus a false innocent result. I breadcrumbed my result as being "75% sure" on day 3 in case I was killed that night (which I was), but that caused most of the town to later think that shaka was a confirmed innocent. It looked like the scum would cruise to a win until the fickle finger of irony struck: the "confirmed town" status that kept shaka from being lynched led to Tarhalindur (the SK) killing him on night 4. shaka killed Tar the same night, handing the town a victory in a game where they only lynched one of the four scum. Not pretty, but I'll take it.
|
| Mini 554: Mafia in Vollville |
vollkan |
Townie |
Survived |
Town Win! |
|
| Very nice game overall for the town, we had two of the scum in our sights from the end of day 1 and managed to lynch correctly three days in a row to close it out, despite losing both pro-town investigators on night 1. I liked the simplicity of this game's setup, as it really allowed the strong scumhunting to shine. One of my better games, I think.
|
| Mini 583: BAMPEG |
pickemgenius |
Cop |
Killed N2 |
Mafia Win |
|
| Kinda "meh" play all round - a modkill ended day 1 very quickly and I got two innocent results and was killed before I could claim. Scum pulled a decent gambit to fool the town on day 3, and that was all they needed to get over the line.
|
| Elemental Mafia |
Battle Mage |
Lover (with armlx) |
Survived |
Town Win! |
|
| This game was built around the concept of four competing cults, but the town ended up lynching most of the recruitable players before they had much of a chance to build their numbers. Only two players ended up being recruited, and the town won comfortably despite a horrible success rate on lynches. Poor curiouskarmadog (the Jester) got nightkilled before the game even started.
|
| Dynamite Stick Mafia |
Mr Stoofer |
?? |
Killed N6 |
Ongoing |
|
|
|
