The worst

I am lazy @ formatting. This is pretty much just a list so I never forget games I was in :)

Newbie 1841: Elves! by fferyllt

Was a Vanilla Townie and survived to win (*cough*CARRIED*cough). My role's greenness was outranked only by my own.

Basically this game would have been an easy scum win if not for an extremely strong replace-in on a townie slot who siteflaked. Sheeped to victory and picked up a lot of handy tips on how to read a mafia game logically. :]

Open 711: Stack The Deck by Mathdino

I was Vanilla Townie and was lynched D2 on a soft guilty, for the loss on D3.

This game will always have a special spot in my heart as I was targeted N1 by the mafia, vigilante and bodyguard. My reads were actually quite good (for a change) but I was a dead duckling walking xD

Newbie 1848 -- The Cookie Jar by insanity018

Replaced into my first scumgame onsite! I was a Mafia Goon, lynched D2 for the loss on D3.

All-in-all I think my buddy and I played an *okay* game. The town here was extremely strong, there probably wasn't much we could do.

Newbie 1852 by nancy

Replaced into another scumgame as a Mafia Rolecop D: luckily survived & won D3! :D

I feel like my play here was pretty average, but it came together in LyLo. I got to use quite a lot of the skills I'd picked up from playing & reading newbie games, it's just a shame it was a scumgame.

Mini 1993 - Earthbound Mafia: Giygas' Curse by Gamma Emerald

Organically rolled Mafia Roleblocker, survived & won D4!

While I'll admit the setup was pretty damn scum-sided, I enjoyed this game a lot. There was really strong town synergy and a lot of interesting roles. It was really good fun exercising how much a townread mafia roleblocker can mess with night action plans. I feel like I played quite well with respect to being townread in this game, but still had terrible associations. With a different player list, I would have been lynched much earlier.

Stockport: A Mafia Story (Episode 1) by Radja

This game had some quirky roles/characters. Basically I was a town PGO, and was endgamed in LyLo D4.

Stockport was really creative, and such an interesting experience to play. The playerlist was pretty quiet, and in the end I was kind of left to my own devices and attempted to solve the game mechanically rather than as a mafia game. The bad news is, that's a terrible idea and the eccentricities of the setup didn't allow for it. The good news is, I shan't do dumb shit like that again. :P

bad Idea Mafia: Still Bad by thestatusquo

does this count?

fuck it why not

this was great

mcmenno like won the game while breaking the record for the shortest d1 in history

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=10077864#p10077864

Mini Theme 2001: Mafia Month by xyzzy this one cemented xyzzy as one of my all time favourite scummers & mods of all time WOAH

so the gimmick here was rather than individual day timelines, all combined day phases of the game had a single 30 day timer.

not finishing the game before the timer resulted in an instant town loss.

I was really really impressed by how active the scumteam were, but I played pretty badly (and got vigged for my efforts).

Mini 1995: The Absolute Worst Game Ever Run

probably doesn't count but I had the honour of being a part of the glorious EldritchAbomination!

mastina's pisstake moderating style here was absolutely hilarious, and better than anything we could really volunteer as the 'worst hydra ever'.

but it was a pleasure being there!