Fferyllt/Games

fferyllt

Games

Modded Games

Terms of Art

Achievements

Modded Games

Avatars

Statistics

Newbie

Newbie 1319 - Bugenhagen's Bungalow
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
chkflip	Mafia Rolecop	Started	Survived	Scum win
My first game. The Acting Method was my scum partner and the IC. Several of the "newbies" were experienced players, notably serrapaladin. I didn't start the game intending to act newbish, but when other players assumed I was relatively inxperienced I didn't correct them, though I did make reference to games on other sites. Town had some bad luck in the form of a Doctor who got many players' backs up on day 1, wound up the lynch leader, and refused to claim. I noticed his PR tells early on, and tried to get a credible alternative wagon on another townie so that when Luisss did eventually claim there would be a place for the votes to go. Instead, he was lynched and my day 1 alternative bandwagon was the day 2 lynch. Then, the game got serious. The jailkeeper, CityElectric, blocked me on night 2 so there was no kill. Fortunately she thought it was possible that she had protected the intended victim and didn't claim or breadcrumb. We killed her on night 3 and sailed to the win on day 4 when one townie voted another. It was a fun game, but really stressful drawing scum in my first MS game. A family member passed away during the game, too, which meant that I wasn't much of a presence on day 2 until the day was nearly done. I didn't start another game until this one ended, in part because I didn't want to blow my not-so-experienced cover. The game was a lot of fun and I've been happy to see that several of the players are still on site and playing games.

Newbie 1351 - Hyrule is Under Attack!
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
TraceyLyn11	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed Night 4	Scum win
This was my second Newbie game. GoodMorning was the IC, and this was our first game together. Day 1 was a long struggle due to several replace-outs and at least one extension so that a last minute replacement would have time to read the game. Three key replacements were VisceraEyes and Ineffective who placed into strongly suspected slots, and GuyInFreezer, who was the Mafia Goon but had inherited a slot that was not under much suspicion. Unshakeable town reads were developed, but many mistakes were made and the game was ultimately won by GIF and Mac. My key takeaways were: just because you know a player is town doesn't mean you want them around at endgame, and no lynch at MYLO should not be considered if you have confirmed town or universally recognized town. We would have won this game if I had objected to no lynch and gone after the player I thought was scum.

Newbie 1358 - Bisquick
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Vanilla Town	Day 1 Page 10	Survived	Town win
This was my first replacement game. It was memorable because it was my game playing with Ineffective and [[AngryPidgeon}} who was the IC. My slot was under suspicion when I replaced in, and I was able to turn that around pretty quickly based on my catch up posts and scum list. I picked out 3 players as scummy, PoEed that down to two and then voted the player who was actually scum. This game was plagued by replacements, including the player I had scum-read and we wound up not killing him until Day 2. Between role claims and a jailkeep after one scum was lynched, AngryPidgeon and I were the most credible alternatives for scum. I waffled, invented scenarios and generally dragged my feet for at least a week before AngryPidgeon was lynched and town won. I still need to work on being more decisive and less paranoid.

Newbie 1364
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
DeasVail	Vanilla Town	Day 1 Page 15	Survived	Town win
This was my second replacement game. I replaced in on page 15 of day 1. The day 1 bandwagons were a quandary because the two main wagons were both scum. I wound up hammering at just before 3 am my time. The second scum was jailkept that night and lynched on day 2, making this a perfect town win. It was a great player list, and I particularly enjoyed meeting FearThePoster and BROseidon. This was the first game where I went into detail about my idiosyncratic meaning for "trajectory" in mafia.

Newbie 1370
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
RachMarie, Malakittens	Vanilla Town	Replaced in Day 4 3P LYLO	Survived	Town win
I replaced into a 3P LYLO with Ms Marangal and Majiffy. My slot was confirmed town because my predecessor hadn't hammered. Sorting out which of Majiffy and Mara were scum and town was a challenge. Meta, personal experience, and the thread itself all pointed vaguely in the direction of Mara. And so it was.

Newbie 1379
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Messiah, Zaicon	Vanilla Town	Replaced in Night 1 Page 18	Survived	Town win
This is the first time that I've replaced in to a slot that was being strongly scum-read. I read the ISO before sending the replacement volunteer PM and didn't see anything objectively scummy. Then I read the thread start to finish and knew I was a potential day 2 mislynch. I got past that on day 2, but it looked like I could become a mislynch at endgame instead. I should have stuck with my day 1 reads on day 3 because I was right.

Newbie 1389 Trouble in River City
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Nobody Special	Vanilla Town	Started	Endgamed	Scum Win
IC, and not such an auspicious first IC game. The team consisted of JasonWazza and Lynx. My play was unspectacular enough to result in 2 days worth of severe tunneling by worthy town players.

Newbie 1403
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Nobody Special	Mafia Goon	Replaced in on day 2	Survived	Scum Win
This is the first game I've replaced into as scum. Thor was my team mate. The town team had some extreme confirmation bias going on, and this turned out to be a fairly easy scum win.

Newbie 1415
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
penguin_alien	Vanilla Town	Replaced in on day 3	Lynched Day 3	Town Win
I started pretty well as a replacement, but misjudged another replacement's ability to read me. Hilarious cross-paranoia ensued. I was lynched, he was NKed as the final mafia goon searched desperately for the other PR. Edosurist pulled off an incredible gambit on day 2 after the being-lynched scum claimed 1-shot bullet-proof. Instead of claiming his actual role (Cop) he counterclaimed BP. The remaining scum (jasonwazza) assumed the game also had a tracker from that misdirection, and was trying to hit the 2nd town PR on night 3. F-16_Fighting_Falcon sprang the trap on day 4 when jason claimed tracker. This was my first game with F16, and it was fun. He's a detail-oriented meta-based player, and spent an amazing amount of time meta-ing 6 of my games. I should really do some sort of index to my games for meta purposes. "good town", "bad town", "good scum", "bad scum". Probably won't though. I'm not sure my categorizations would match what others would think, anyway.

Newbie 1417
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
jasonwazza	Vanilla Town	Replaced in on day 4	Survived	Town Win
Day 4 ended quickly. Last scum was pretty obvious at that point, and I replaced into a really obvious town slot. Short, sweet, and fun.

Newbie 1429 - N is for Newbie
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
N, Cheery Dog	Vanilla Town	Replaced in on page 10,day 1	Killed by scum night 1	Mafia win
This was a perfect scum win. beginner dropped a "townslip" that should serve as a warning to never take townslips at face value. GiF did a great job of rehabilitating the other scum slot, and Bert kept up the good work. F-16 replaced into beginner's slot on day 3 lylo and played excellently. Neither scum player was under any pressure at all. My contribution in my 4 days in the game was to whip up a bandwagon on the 1-shot bulletproof PR. She self-hammered without claiming.

Newbie 1436
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
malakittens	Mafia Goon	Replaced in on page 4,day 1	Survived	Mafia Win
This game was in theory a Newbie game, but by mid-day 1 only one actual newbie hadn't replaced out. Cabd and I replaced in together on page 4 and I was the one who unfortunately drew the scum position. The other scum slot was filled by gravija, Kazekirimaru, Mario4 and finally Wisdom. Cabd self-hammered, ending day 2. Wisdom was lynched on day 3, and LYLO consisted of Bert, notscience, and me. Against all expectations, Bert voted notsci, and I, in mid-reply, hammered. This is the 2nd game where I have claimed scum in a post. This one wasn't spotted either until too late. I should really stop doing that, but I couldn't pass up the opportunity just this one last time. I think I've had too many scum games recently. It's warping my outlook on life.

Newbie 1460: The Not-So InnocentVillage
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
innocentvillager	Mafia Goon	Started	Lynched day 3	Mafia Win
This was my second IC game and I drew scum this time. Not my best play, in part due to the Christmas holidays and some extremely distracting IRL stuff, and in part due to playing 2 or 3 other scum games simultaneously. I almost got my desired lynch on day 1 but it turned out I'd built my case on the Town Cop. Nacho replaced in to my partner's slot partway through day 1. I claimed doc when I reached L-1 with less than a day left before deadline, and it actually worked. I somehow slipped past the lynch on day 2 as well, but after that it was pretty much inevitable. The next day, Nacho won when a town player put a vote down on town at LYLO. JasonWazza spotted me really early (page 2 or 3). Wisdom replaced into that slot and also had me as scum right from the start. Fortunately, he spent a lot of time partner hunting, and actually led the lynch on another town player on day 2 thinking he was my partner.

Newbie 1471: Italian Ice
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyinFreezer	Vanilla Town	Replaced in Day 1, page 39	Survived	Town Win
Game ended on day 3 with the lynch of the last scum. I was really happy with my reads in this game, and thought that the town players did a great job of playing like they were town. So did the scum players.

Newbie 1485: Water Balloon Battle Royale
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
CheeryDog		Replaced in Day 1, page 6
In Progress.

Micro

Micro 152 - BSG Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
AngryPidgeon	Vanilla Town	Started	Day 1 Lynch (self hammered)	Town Win
This was my first MS game with buldermar and Syryana, and my second with orcinus_theoriginal. There were other players of note as well. For me, this was a terrible game. It was the first time at MS I had a strong town read on a player on page 1. Saying that on page 1 was a terrible idea, and it got worse from there. buldermar was scum and did a great job of taking advantage of the paranoia I sowed, and I did a terrible job of sticking with my reads. Eventually, I self-hammered. Something I'm not likely to do again any time soon. This game was where the idea for the Selkies hydra was born. And town won. The scum team was buldermar and pitoli. AngryPidgeon is a fantastic mod. I look for his games in sign-ups.

borkgame as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Town Innocent Child	Started	Survived	Town Win
This was the first game where orcinus and I played as Selkies. It was also the first game where I saw a semi-effective town block form. orcinus came up with the strategy of fake-claiming PGO to hopefully prevent our being the night 1 kill. It worked. But, it was not the last town lie of the game. ArcAngel9 also lied about her doctor role, saying she was a one-shot bodyguard. She didn't believe our claim, so protected us on night 2. Scum didn't believe our claim either. We went through 2 days without lynching scum, and then town got its act together. Arcangel9 protected us again on night 2 and from there it was an autowin situation. Majiffy was lynched on day 3 and Jennifer on day 4. It was a tense and at times contentious game for town, but in the end things came together.

Micro 162 - Poetic Justice
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
AngryPidgeon	3rd Party (Assassin)	Started	Night 1 assassin & mafia kill	Town Win
I lost this game when I selected two night actions from a list. I should have chosen a night kill instead of 2 investigative roles. I plugged along and helped town to a win with my day 1 play. On night 1, I watched/tracked the last scum player and saw him visit me. And then I died. :D It was another great group of players. The micro queue attracts really good mafiascum players. The scum team was Majiffy and Mac.

Micro 161: No-Newbie Newbie as ² with buldermar
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
N	Vanilla Town	Started	Endgamed	Scum Win
This was our first game as ². The scum team of Mr E Roll and Red Coyote played well.

MICRO 172: DRAGON BALL Z
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
chkflip	Town Miller Fisherman	Started	Survived	Town Win
This started as a difficult game due to not knowing any of the players besides bacde. I decided not to claim miler on the offhand chance that I'd get a useful one-shot via fishing. Vegito (Majiffy/Nacho hydra) replaced in and the game turned funny, though they were in the lynch lead for much of the game. Another replacement, mrbungle had a key role. At the end of the day, we ran up several players to L-1, forced nearly every PR to claim, and finally lynched scum. That night, Vegito tracked the final scum to his kill. We argued a bit, decided to wait for the scum player to post, then mrbungle took matters into his own hands and executed Beliasaurus. Perfect town win. The scum team was Ghostlin and Beliasaurus

Micro 174 The Half Baked Curse as Noeffencllue with Ineffective
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
RachMarie	Town Odd Night Shaman (Doc)	Started	Killed by Mafia Night 1	Town Win
We lynched scum on day 1, but were erroneously deathtunneling the Nero Cain/Ms Marangal hydra, Sugar Cain. Just as well we died night 1.

Micro 177: Goonies Mafia as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
jake from state farm	Vanilla Town	Started	Replaced out	Town Win
Replaced out on day 1 due to a personal conflict with the moderator. Not included in win/loss statistics.

Micro 182 - MS Buzzword Bingo as ² with buldermar
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
angrypidgeon	Town Cop	Started	Killed by Mafia Night 1	Town Win
The set up was 5 vanilla town, 2 millers, cop and role cop for town, and godfather and goon for scum. Though the set-up was a little townsided, town dominated this game due to the players being so familiar with each other. By page 2 a town core of 3 had formed, and by page 8 the core had 5 members, most of whom were agreed (and correct) about the identity of the scum team. It was a bit of a struggle to get from there to a lynch. Perfect town win. We lynched the godfather on day 1, and viewed the final scum on night 1 but didn't live to tell the tale. The scum team was mastin2 and nachomamma8

Micro 186: Vengeball as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
CheeryDog	Vengeful Townie	Started	Survived	Town Win
This was the first Rift Adrift game. The 9p vengeball format was great. This was the first nightless game I actually enjoyed playing.

Micro 217: Achievement Unlocked, later renamed Morph the Cat Goes Platinum as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Nachomamma8	muddying the waters scum	Started	Survived	Scum win
If we completed all our personal achievements (which involved ridiculously scummy behaviors including claiming scum and derphammering), and survived to day 3 we would earn a day kill. Achievement unlocked. Game won. It was fun, and not quite as daunting as the Xenologue game, though being scum in a game with town-Bulbazak was pretty scary. At long last, vengeance for the Donner Party game.

Micro 231: Mismatching Flavor Mafia as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyInFreezer	Mafia Strongman	Replaced in on late Day 1	Survived	Scum win
Cabd and I replaced in as Morph the Cat. Bert was the other scum player, and he did a fantastic job. He was considered the least likely of the "non-confirmed" players to be scum. Prior to replacing in, Cabd was playing solo. After 2 Morph scum games where I was very much in the background, I made it a point in this game to be a stronger presence. The slot was under suspicion on day 1 and the game day ended before I had a chance to do a catch up post. So, on Day 2 I started with a lot of poking, prodding and questioning of players and held off posting my reads list for a day or 2. This was an effort to conform to my evolving town-replacement play, and it's something that maybe only I notice or care about! Despite my deep and abiding dislike and fear of scum roles, I agreed to replace in for three reasons: I don't want to give the impression that I only replace in to slots that I am townreading because 1) I don't and 2) it could easily become an implicit truth tell if people assume I do. I'd rather my play be evaluated more rationally. The third reason, which I didn't get to test, was to see if I could plant any doubt about our alignment in the Nacho head of Mononoke. Nacho wasn't fooled. But I still think I did a fair job of making a scummy looking (and actually scum) slot look a little more town. On night 2, we decided to fake claim Hider with an innocent result on Brian Skies. There was sufficient "evidence" for that claim in the game thread, and I made the claim in the first post of Day 3. I was impressed with Brian Skies' play. He knew something was up, and even though the case for scum-me that he was working on was flawed, the fact that he was working on a case at all was impressive.

Micro 231: Micro 246: Chosen Mafia as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Syryana	Vanilla Town	Started	Night 1 Scum Kill	Scum win
Bert almost got a townbloc together on day 2 that could have pulled a victory out. It was not to be.

Micro 252: There Is No Doctor as sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Bmolla	Werewolf	Started	Lynched Day 3	Town Win
This was a tough game. Town played really well, and Especially the Lies and The Purple Rose made the right decision at LYLO.

Micro 258: Pick & Ban as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyInFreezer	Vanilla Town	Started	Survived	Town Win
It was an experimental game design that Natirasha created and GiF ran. Nacho's sorting methodology was pretty intense, but since this was Morph the Cat we had it coming. We lynched scum on day 1, and I had the 2nd scum pegged, but Nacho disagreed, so we lynched lurky town on day 2. Sakura jailkept the final scum that night and town won with the day 3 lynch.

Micro 267 - Indie Game: The UPick as Trine (Zoya head) with Bulbazak (Amadaeus) and Cabd (Pontius)
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Alduskkel	Town JOAT (Commuter, Roleblocker, Doctor	Started	Survived	Town Win
The game had some unique roles. We did something somewhat unorthodox (commuted when the town hider intended to hide behind us, but given the scum power (mega-joat and redirector), it turned out that our night action choice was probably the optimal thing to have done. We got into a 1v1 with the scum joat (ETL) on day 2 and at the last minute rather than lynching one of us, we lynched the scum redirector instead (Penguin_Alien/Malakittens hydra). On night 2 we roleblocked ETL and the rest was history. It was a very nice win after a very rocky day 1.

Micro 278 - Normalized Fun as Sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
JacobSavage	Town Tracker	Started	Survived	Town Win
Day 1 wasn't so great. We had both scum in our townpile. But, we corrected course on night 1 and tracked Empking to a player who didn't die (the bodyguard died). We got him to L-1, and he claimed...tracker! Counterclaim ho, Kalimar confirmed town by Empking's targeting him. We had the 2nd scum identified as the next lynch in priority. Night 2, instead of dying as we expected, there was no kill, and we tracked RedCoyote going nowhere. This created some hesitance and uncertainty, but in the end we lynched him correctly. AngryPidgeon replaced into this game. This was the first time he's been town in one of my games. I figured him out, but he was still mislynched on day 1. :/

Micro 278 - Micro 283: Mistakes UPick
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyinFreezer	Town Innocent Child	Replaced in on day 1, page 11	Died Night 2	Scum Win
At the time of my replacement, my slot had already been confirmed innocent child, so I didn't expect to survive night 1. Day 2 was way too fast in retrospect, and that helped set up the town loss. In LYLO, the doctor, thinking that the player voting him was the last scum self-voted to prove that. And of course the last scum (tiershift) hammered. This is an object lesson about proving points at LYLO.

Micro 285 - Time: The Distortion as Scumfuck with Belisarius
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
MaJiffy	Vanilla Town	Started	Survived	Town Win
I love this hydra name. This was our first game as a hydra, and it went pretty well. It seemed like there was more paranoia about me than Beli, which was interesting given his scum game. But, we towned it adequately. This was a fun player group and the game design was unusual. MaJiffy was testing out a mechanic he wants to use in a large theme game. Luck went against scum-Domo re the mechanic. We would have died on night 1 without the mechanic, which would have wasted the Cop's investigation of us.

Micro 326: Let the Love Spread
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyInFreezer		Replaced in, Day 1 Page 13
In Progress

Open

Open 485 - Polygamist
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
TraceyLyn11	Town Lover	Started	Endgamed	Scum win
This was my third game on-site and my first with orcinu_theoriginal, Ms Marangal and Klick. My lover replaced out and was replaced by Svenskt Stål. It was a fun game, and ultimately Town lost. The scum team was Ms Marangal, leviathan93, Voodoo Lady and Nekoko.

Open 490: Donner Party Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Zaicon	Vanilla Town	Started	Endgamed	SK win
A very bad town game on my part. By the final day that town could win (which we didn't know due to night kills not being flipped), I felt I had no credibility to set a lynch direction, so all I could really do was dig my heels in over what I (correctly) thought was a mislynch. The next day, it 1-1-1. I picked the mafia player to hammer and the SK won. The scum team was Malakittens and Goodmorning. The SK was bulbazac

Open 491: The Popcorn Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Sanjay	Mafia goon	Started	Day 2 shot	Town win
This setup has been discontinued due to being excessively townsided. Even so, my play was lackluster. Still, a fun game in many ways.

Open 510: DUCK DUCK GOOSE as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Ms Marangal	Mafia goon	Started	Survived	Scum win
GiF's awesome night kill choices won this game.]

Open 527 - Hard Boiled: Dixon Hill's Maudlin Madness as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Syryana	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed Night 3	Town Win
This was a fun game. Our reads were not so great, but I think we would have made some course corrections about Majiffy/Mara hydra after Trolling Fairy (lol Cabd/Nacho) flipped scum. As conftown after not quickhammering in LYLO, Cephrir had the task of figuring whether scum was VioleNt Saxophone (Majiffy/Mara) or Cait Sith (Tammy/Mala).

Open 534 - Killing at the Frat as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
BROseidon	Vanilla Town	Replaced in Day 1, page 16	Night Killed Night 1	Scum Win
We were right about one scum while we were in the game. It was a perfect scum win.

Mini Normal

Mini 1469: Rage as morph the cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
GuyInFreezer	SK, 1 Shot Commuter	Started	Lynched day 3	Mafia win
Scum-Cheery Dog outed as scum Jailkeeper (was goon) and led a lynch on me. One town player voted with the 3 scum and it was game over. This one goes into my wtf scrapbook. Probably the worst thing I did this game was scum-read serrapaladin (the town JOAT) because he wasn't pushing lynches, although he was trying to derail a couple of bad bandwagons. I nightkilled him on night 2 instead of my next scummiest read (who was scum).

Mini 1496: The Cash Cabd as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cabd	Town Compulsive Neighborizer	Started	Survived	Town win
The game was a lot of fun, which sort of breaks my Mini Normal paradigm. Getting a neighborizer role contributed massively to my sense of fun. So did neighborizing Rebel Without a Pulse (Nacho/Stubbs), who turned out to be the doctor. This turned out to be synergistic because Nacho and I could talk through the game. We wound up correctly identifying the cop (Rail Tracer - zmuffinman hydra) and Nacho protected him the night that he was targeted by the scum kill. I had to replace out at the end of night 3 because of a mod communication that accidentally spoilered the last scum's identity. Guy in Freezer carried on from there, and reaction tested the final scum. NotScience's reaction to that test turned the vote into a serious vote. The rest is history.

Mini 1501: We're On A Boat
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
pitoli	1-Shot Bullet-Proof Town	Started	Lynched day 4	SK Win
This was an enjoyable game. Town played well for the most part, but some key mislynches and erroneous set-up spec led to the loss. This may be the most inexplicable lynch I've ever experienced. It was a great player list and I hope to play with them again sometime soon.

Mini 1516: Mafia in Space as Street Hassle with Empire
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
F-16_Fighting_Falcon	Vanilla Town	Started	Lynched Day 3	Scum win
The town doctor fake-claimed a guilty on me at the start of day 1, and didn't admit to the gambit until after I had been lynched. Much yelling and profanity ensued. He was lynched the following day rather than obvscum who had claimed odd night Vig on day 1. Will avoid the player in the future. Other than that, it was an interesting game, and was my first playing with Regfan.

Mini 1532: Mac's Mini Normal as Sound of Silence with GuyinFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Mac	Mafia Goon	Started	Lynched Day 1	Town Win
Pretty terrible showing on my part. I blame the holidays, and maybe some fatigue with being scum in several games at once.

Mini 1543--Natirasha's On Parole! as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Natirasha	Mafia Traitor	Started	Survived	Mafia Win
Being a traitor was an interesting experience. The scum team found me pretty quickly and I was recruited on night 2. I was brought to L-1 twice on day 1, and basically approached the game from a sowing-chaos perspective since I expected to be lynched pretty quickly after such a difficult day 1. I distanced/bussed one scum mercilessly, and more or less ignored the other scum aside from an occasional raised eyebrow. And I did similar stuff with town players. I was brought to L-1 again on day 2 iirc, and then on day 3 was actually saved from lynch by the nightfall deadline. And then, one scum slipped and with his cardflip the other scum was revealed and orcinus and I were on our own by day 5. We nk'd cabd-vig, night 5 and then on night 6 made what may have been a game-winning decision, though at the start of day 6 I regretted it. Day 6 we were at mylo with nachomamma8, zmuffin and guyett. Night 6 we no-killed. That lack of kill, along with the missing kill on night 2 when we were recruited caused a lot of confusion. It looked like nacho would be the day 7 lynch but I dug in and refused to consider his lynch. With about a day and a half left, I posted a nolynch vote and that broke the logjam. zmuffinman asked me who I thought was scum. Answer "you". guyett asked me why I didn't vote and I gave a variety of conflicting reasons. guyett voted him and I made 2 posts. One, sans vote, "now we're conf town" and a minute later, the hammer. It's pretty much exactly as I had hoped the game would unfold. After 3 games losing to scum teams including nacho and muffin, I was pretty motivated to win this game if possible, and by getting one of them lynched. preferably muffin, though this has no doubt wrecked some of my meta surrounding the lengths I'll go as town to prevent a nacho lynch when I'm townreading him. Not that I'll be discouraged from going to those lengths in the future when I think he's town. scum won this game in lylo because town-nacho and town-zmuffin didn't find each other. Scum made it to lylo because town made a lot of errors.

Mini 1584--Neuroscience Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Kagami	Vanilla Town	Replaced in on Day 1	Killed Night 3	Werewolf Win
Town didn't realize this was two full scum teams. We were looking for an SK after flipping two mafia on day 1 and 2. This was my first game with several of the players, and that was genuinely fun. AngryPidgeon (who replaced in) had me as scum or sk on day 2 and 3, but wasn't able to get me lynched fortunately. After this game he threw his hands up for a while and stopped trying to read me. I scumread Nati on day 1 (and her replacement), and Thor on day 2 (he was also a replacement). This game lived up to the mini normal meta of having a ton of replacements.

Mini Themed

Mini 1451: A Memory of Light as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cephrir	Town Ability Cop, etc	Started	Killed by scum night 3	Scum win
Pretty much shellacked by GoodCop_BadCop and Ms Marangal. And people wonder why I'm so paranoid

ACCESS CODE 1461: Paradox Prime as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
AurorusVox	Morbid Townie	Started	Killed by scum Night 3	Town win
This game had some amazing mechanics, including a role that could neighborize a living player after death, and a mechanism to bring all the dead players back to life for a day and return the game temporarily to day 1. MC Maraca (Cabd/Ms Marangal hydra) carried off three separate gambits to help town come back from a ton of mislynches and win the game. One of the gambits was a fake innocent investigation results on yours truly. The game also featured lots of puppies, Clint Eastwood gifs and the amazing portmanteau "RiftSixtian". Would play again.

Mini 1479: Perpetual MYLO II as sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Wickedestjr	Townie	Started	Killed by scum Night 1	Town win
This was a perfect town win. Nacho and I correctly identified 4 out of 5 scum on day 1, barely escaped being lynched by the skin of our teeth, and led a successful bandwagon on our top scum pick. Two more scum lynches later and the game was won. Nacho had hoped for a scum role in this one, and given the starting proportions of 7-5 the odds were pretty good. But, the random numbers did what they tend to do in my presence.

Mini 1478 ~ Mafia Xenologue as morph the cat with Cabd]
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Vi	Mafia 1-shot commuter, neighborizer	Started	Survived	Mafia Win
It was a quick but not so graceful win. Mafia wins seem to come in two flavors, where town eats itself alive, and where scum play a flawless game. This game was more of the former than the latter, but even so I thought town might pull it out. The highlight (or perhaps lowlight) of the game was killing Oil Tycoons on night 1 and then finding them still alive on day 2. Due to role mechanics they survived until nightfall of day 2. And then they NEIGHBORIZED US FROM THE GRAVE and gave us a double vote for the day. That arguably settled the day 2 lynch. All in all, a nerve wracking game that hardly felt like a perfect scum win. There was some great scum strategy involved thanks to Cabd and Andrius. My main contribution was somehow appearing townlike enough to Oil Tycoons until they were finally for really reals dead and banished to the dead QT.

Mini 1490 - Chef Mafia as Trebuchet Tabby with malakittens]
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
quadz08 Starring as Alton Brown	Mafia ascetic 1 shot BP	Started	Lynched day 2	Town win
d3x struggled on in admirable form. The setup was townsided, but scum lost based on play IMO, with the exception of d3x. He had a posting restriction, but voluntarily increased the restriction exponentially, which made his posts nearly impossible to understand. It was awesome and awesomely funny.

Mini 1492: Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Nexus	Mafia Goon (Basilisk	Started	Lynched day 5	Scum Win
This was a really hard-fought game that I didn't expect scum to win. My making it to day 5 before being lynched was amazing given that I had to make all kills and town had so many ways to find me. But, I did last until PoE virtually assured I had to be scum, and Nacho was able to get the last needed mislynch on the following day in 3-person lylo. This may be the game that I look back on and say "There - right there. That is where I conceded the meta war."

Mini 1508: Tales of uPick
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Elize Lutus aka feirei	Town modified tree stump	Started	Abandoned	Distraught
Game had to be abandoned due to some errors in the role pms and opening post. Was very sad not to have the opportunity to come back into the game thread after my death, set up shop and scumhunt for the duration of the game. As someone who is often an early NK this role was pretty much a dream come true - flip confirmed town and then continue to play the game sans vote.

Mini 1515: Touhou Imperishable Night as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Town Unrequited Lover	Started	Died when scum lover was lynched Day 2	Mafia Win
Game was fun, design was super-swingy, and town lost after 2 mislynches which is pretty amazing in a mini! Scum had a 2nd kill (poison). Town PRs were overpowered as hell, so it was pretty amazing that scum won this so handily. congrats to GiFNacho hydra, BROseidon and zmuffinman.

Mini 1520: Neighborhood Mafia as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
ThAdmiral	Town Tree Stump Neighborizer	Replaced in on Day 1	Endgamed	Mafia Win
The game design had some issues, but town was completely outplayed. When we neighborized scum-notsci, the game was over

Mini 1525: Tales of The Abyss Mafia as Deacon Blues with BorkJerfkin
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cabd and Syryana	Town 1-shot Necromancer (neighborize a dead player	Started	Night Killed Night 1	Mafia Win
Town had this won after a long slog, until one of the town neighbors hammered the other (after he'd been confirmed town by the hider earlier in the game) at LYLO.

Mini 1526: OCRemix Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Bulbazak	Mafia Roleblocker	Replaced in on Day 2, page 42	Survived	Mafia Win
It should have been an easy 5p LYLO win on day 5. Instead it was a nailbiter 3p LYLO on day 6. I brought Natirasha nad notsci to LYLO. Nati voted me. I crossed. A few days later, notsci hammered...Nati. I had a ton of fatalism, but didn't entirely give up. The fatalism was evident in my play and notsci misinterpreted it as town wanting to give up.

Mafia Pinnipedum as Selkies with orcinus_theoriginal
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Sixty, hydra of Vi and Tierce	Roleblocker & Tracker	Started	Survived	Mafia Win
It was a perfect scum win, mostly thanks to Cabd's hydra totally winning the trust of a town mason after neighborizing her. She claimed he was her mason rather than neighbor. This gave the scum team the leverage to pull off 3 town lynches in a row, including the lynch of the town compulsive vigilante. This was my second game sort of getting past town-Nacho. He didn't townread me, but he wasn't sure enough I was scum to go after me. Penguin_Alien was sure, but kept choosing other "scummier" targets to go after first. It wasn't a great performance on my part, but it was good enough.

Mini 1551: Tales of Vesperia Mafia as Deacon Blues with BorkJerfkin
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cabd	Town enabled Vig	Started	Killed Night 3	Mafia Win
Worst misread of the game was my town-orcinus read. 2nd worse was scumreading Kaze/Kagami hydra. Our first vig kill was reasonable. The second one, not so much. We were enabled/checked by the town lover/masons, GreyICE and Tammy. It was a swingy game, but fun to play.

Mini 1555 Board Game UPick Mafia as morph the cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
The Betting Pool (penguin_alien and Lucky2u	Town Redirector and Post Restriction Gifter	Started	Lynched day 5	Town Win
This was the first and so far only game where Morph has been lynched. And of course that would happen in a town game. Our night action never manifested in the game. We were scumblocked on nights 1 and 3, jailkept by highshroomish (as a protection) on nights 1 and 2) and on night 4, when we followed the plan put forth by a town and scum player (yeah, that was a great idea!), the player we targeted of course was the scum kill. I am a little bitter about how other town players in the game treated us, but between our role's unprovability and my less than stellar day-play due to real life distractions, I can't really blame them for not giving us a decent review the day we were lynched. On the plus side, we were in on 2 scum lynches, targeted scum once, and would have targeted the last scum if we hadn't followed the plan. On day 4 I waffled between the two remaining scum players with my suspicions and vote, but also had some massive paranoia attacks about a town player (SpyreX) who had fooled me in the two games we had played prior to this one. On the final night, after our lynch, Porkens watched the player who was NK'd and saw the perp. The 3P LYLO ended pretty quickly with the last scum's lynch.

Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete as Sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed Night 2	Town Win
We got the Bert/Mara hydra wrong.

Mini 1567: Such Unusual Pretermen as Geists with Natirasha
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Empking	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed Night 2	Mafia Win
Strange game. We didn't solve it.

Mini 1568: Awesome Alliterative Adventure
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
N	Vanilla Town	Replaced in Day 4	Endgamed	Mafia Win
TSO and toolenduso played an excellent scum game. I mislynhced Riptide (Peng/BPC hydra)

Large Normal

NY 164: Maniacal Street Mafia as ffullisade with Pirate Mollie
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
mastin2	Vanilla Town	Replaced in on Night 1	Killed by scum Night 8	Blue Scum Win
Replaced in as hydra after half of Beauty and the Beast was force-replaced. The scum teams were uneven, 3-4. I figured the game out very late - day 7 and helped get the last red scum lynched. I spent most of day 8 MYLO arguing with PeregrineV that there was only one scum left and it wasn't Nacho. He didn't believe me. We nolynched over my haiku-laced objections. I died night 8. And Peregrine hammered Nacho for the loss. This was my first and so far only replace-in to a 120-some page day 1. I think the lack of catch maybe hurt me a little, but I'm pretty happy that lightning struck on day 7 and I had the game solved even if I couldn't convince Pere.

NY 165: A Large Normal as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
PeregrineV	Town Tracker	Started	Killed by scum Night 6	Mafia Win
The town bloc was infiltrated from day 1. KingCrabd was involved in the formation or affirmation of many of my day 1 reads, and took full advantage of the opportunity to sway them. By day 4 I became convinced he was scum but doubted my own reasoning. In some ways this loss is worse than AMoL because I knew what he was capable of as scum.

NY 167: COMPLETELY NORMAL Mafia as Sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
goodmorning	Mafia Encryptor	Started	Scum conceded day 4	Town Win
A short and terrible (for scum) game. We didn't want to give up, even so.

NY 169: The EPIC XD Mafia Game of Greatness as Geists with Natirasha
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Empire	VAnilla Town	Started	Killed Night 5	Town Win
I had some decent reads, but overall played pretty meh this game. I suspected Nacho/Casso early on, but let him off the hook by late day 1 after he dismantled a wagon he sterted on Sakura. And I defended him pretty hard as the game progressed after that. I was investigated by the gunsmith (domo) on night 1 and curiously found that being conf town (aside from paranoia about a mafia doctor, somewhat fueled by scum, but mostly pushed by town) took the edge off my scumhunting. On the final day, Sakura was persuaded by pieguyn to hammer Casso, and town win it was.

Large Themed

Amnesiac
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
T-Bone	Day 1 - Rolestopper	Started	Killed by scum Night 1	Scum win
Setup was fascinating. This was my first game after my initial Newbie, and marked my stepping out into the larger MS community. My play wasn't too bad, but I should have tried harder to get one of my scum reads lynched.

HunterxHunterxMafia: Yorknew City as ² with buldermar
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
hitogoroshi	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed by scum night 1	Town win
Great game, nominated by the Mod for a best town performance. I wish we had been in the game a little longer, but night 1 kill it was.

Xenoblade Mafia as ² with buldermar
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Red Scum Ability Cop	Started	Lynched Day 1	Blue scum win
I didn't get to play for long, but the game was also a lot of fun to watch. GuyInFreezer played a hell of a Red Scum game, as did TiphaineDeath. BROseidon pulled out a Blue scum win with Orcinus and RachMarie.

Mafia of the Raptured
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Vi	Vanilla town	Started	endgamed	Scum win
Probably my worst town performance ever. It will take a while to process all the lessons that should be learned from this one. The playerlist was amazing, though, and this was a first game with several players with whom I hope to play many more games.

Dr Who: The Last Great Time War as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
jasonT1981	Vanilla Town	Started	Scum Killed Night 3	Dalek Scum Win
I played ok in this game: spotted that there was something off about Vi, enjoyed the hell out of my first game with several players, including Faraday, who is entertaining to play with, and who did so much organizing and scumhunting that I got kinda lazy as day 2 progressed.

Death's Diner as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
4nxi3ty	Town 1-shot Vig	Started	Killed Night 5 by scum	Scum win
I had some good town reads in this game but a couple of critical bad reads, both of whom were alive at endgame. I was neighborized by oriole on night 1. He happened to be my strongest town read from day 1 and Syr and I were referring to oriole as our in-thread mason even before the neighborization. We used the one-shot vig on a town player who we most likely would otherwise have tunneled for the rest of the game. Many town mistakes, including ours helped pave the way for a scum victory.

The Walking Dead Mafia! as sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Venmar	Vanilla Town	Started	Night 5 scum kill	Town win
Our role in this game was apparently to defend town PRs (Sugar Cain, OhGodMyLife, Borkjerfkin) from other town and from scum (Thor). Thor did a great job of burrowing his way into the townbloc and sowing dissent. Poor play on the part of the recruited Traitor (TheIrishPope) was a big factor in the scum loss.

Xenogears Mafia as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Borkjerfkin	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed by Scum Night 1	Town win
This game was nearly as fun to watch as to play. Except for the part where all the unconfirmed town agreed to be lynched before the final scum. This plan would have worked except for one minor glitch where a confirmed townie hammered the super saint. The game went to 3 player lylo with Varsoon and Cabd crossvoting and Antihero (who should have been confirmed town BEFORE he didn't hammer). After a few tense days of argument and setup spec and balance debates, Antihero hammered scum.

Fire Emblem: Awakening Mafia as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cephrir	Vanilla Town Childbearer	Started	Killed Night 3	Town Win
The game was basically won on day 1 when the marriage mechanic was all but broken. All the marriages save one were town-town and scum were able to "corrupt" only one child. It took a while to PoE things down to the last scum parent, and then the last child. The janitored flips of "families" caused some delays. All in all, an excellent game by town, and a fascinating design by Cephrir.

Oz Mafia: Based on the HBO Series as Rift Adrift with Syryana
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Majiffy	Cult Leader	Started	Killed by Aryan Faction Night 5	Cult win
It was a crazy bastard set up, but as long as I survived a reasonable number of game days the cult had a good chance of pulling it off. Thor's strategy after we recruited him set us up for the win. With one kill, we eliminated 3 players. That's right, kill. All the factions were receiving night actions from the enabler faction. As well as recruiting, we had 1 night kill, 2 poisonings, a rolecop and a lynchproof. we used 1 kill, 1 poisoning and the rolecop. The other poisoning was used, but the game ended before that player died.

Marketplace Mafia III as morph the cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Magua	Town Entrepreneur	Started	Killed Night 4	Scum Win
Scum played very well. The game design actually penalized town for cooperating, which was quite disappointing.

Red Wine Mafia
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
mykonian	Vanilla Town	Started	Endgamed	Scum Win
Two key misreads led to this loss. Tammy and Empire both replaced out partway through day 1 and were both scum. Tammy in particular had towned her role hard, including hardbussing the godfather. Guyett, Tammy's replacement would probably have been lynched if he'd replaced in to a different slot.

Song Contest U-Pick as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Matias and Quadz	Town 1-shot bulletproof	Replaced in on Day 1, page 26		Mafia Win
Pretty poor showing in a lot of ways. There was one mafia player I townread and never rethought. The others I at least considered at times and reviewed. No wonder I was alive at LYLO.

Xenosaga Mafia as Sangres with Nachomamma8
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
borkjerfkin	Town Mason Neighbor	Started	Killed Night 6	Town Win
I thought we played a solid game through day 3. After that, not so much. Nacho and I mildly disagreed on the final scum (Mollie) and on our last day in the game had our vote on her for at least part of the day. Once we were out of the game, the tide turned pretty quickly and she was lynched on day 7 to end the game. Our 5-player neighborhood contained both a scum and the SK. The SK was rooted out first, and that gave the scum player a little breathing room.

Left 4 Dead Mafia! as sekai no ki with pieguyn
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Venmar	Vanilla Town	Started	Killed Night 4	Mafia Win
The strange thing about this game was that it seemed like I had phenomenal cosmic power to sway the lynch even though a fair number of town players scumread me. I never did get completely out of the cloud of suspicion but also never got run all the way up to lynch. I should have lynched Majiffy. And Svenskt.

Dark Age of the Law Mafia as Sound of Silence with GuyInFreezer
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
MafiaSSK	Town Flavor Innocent Child	Started	Survived	Town Win
Our play wasn't exactly stellar. We were townreading scum nachobert on day 1. After that was sorted we improved, but weren't a huge factor in winning the game.

Tales of You as Breakfast with Stalin with belisarius
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cabd	Town Amnesiac Observer	Started	Killed Night 5	Mafia Win
Reads were pretty bad. Lost it with Mastin's suspicion of us on Day 2 and got her lynched. Correctly read Rancid Broderick Drake due to an amazing reach out from Nati. Had Bork-Nacho wrong due to Bork towning it up. Orcinus Gladiated us and another town player at the end of Day 1. We won the battle, but didn't feel great about that. I was forced-replaced due to an inadvertent spoiler from the mod, but Beli played on in our slot. I count this as a loss.

Final Radiant Tales as Morph the Cat with Cabd
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Natirasha	Heroic Time God	Started	Committed Suicide Day 3	Town Win
MafiaSSK loverized us on Night 2. We got him lynched on Day 3 and wound up dying with him. It was not surprising, but it was also a decent trade. ETL had gone after us pretty hard on Day 1, which was weird and didn't work. Turned out she was an SK. Town did a good job of mopping up and getting the last scum, Oversoul. We would have turned into some sort of indie role if we had "evolved". I'm just as happy that didn't happen.

Inuyashi as Geists with Natirasha
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Cephrir	Town Human Vanilla	Started	Killed Night 2	Scum Team 2 Win
We destroyed one of the scum teams and let the third coast unscathed to a win. This was a large, noisy game and the scum hydra made it even noisier. I would never tolerate that kind of noise today. We were pressuring a couple of scum team 2 on day 1 and 2 which is no doubt why we died as early as we did.

Serum & Steel 2 as Pixel with Kazekirimaru
Modded by	Role	Entry	Status	Outcome
Natirasha	Town Scavenger (could take bulletproof from one player and give to another	Started	Killed Night 4	Town Win
We came under a lot of suspicion on Day 1, and fought through it. Kaze siteflaked during Day 1. Zmuffinman neighborized us on Night 1. I townread the hell out of him, and explained my role to him on Night 2. Tammy's hydra had an incredibly powerful town role that scum would want to eliminate. I took Zmuffin's Steel (bulletproof) and gave it to Tammy. He died on Night 2. Night 3 I did something dumb - took Town Antihero's Steel and gave it to scum-Marquis. Antihero was not pleased! I was NKed on night 4. I didn't realize we had a 2nd scum team. I didn't scumread pieguyn for it but her tunnel on Cephrir's alt was a horrible thing to see. Fortunately, the steel got Tammy to endgame and she won it for town. My night 2 action was the best thing I did all game, and it wouldn't have happened without Zmuffin volunteering his steel for Tammy. This probably makes no sense at all to a nonplayer, but it's what stands out to me about the game.