You are viewing the MafiaScum.net Wiki. To play the game, visit the forum.

Pitoli: Difference between revisions

From MafiaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
 
(33 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 6: Line 6:
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|-
|-
|[[]]
|[[File:Jessica.jpg]]
|[[File:Rapunzel.png]]
|[[File:Rapunzel.png]]
|[[File:Chen.png]]
|[[File:Chen.png]]
|[[File:Chanyeol.png]]
|[[File:Chanyeol.png]]
|[[File:Luhan.png]]
|[[File:Kyungsoo_reindeer.png]]
|-
|-
|Jessica
|Jessica
|Rapunzel
|Rapunzel
|Chen
|Chen
|Chanyeol (current)
|Chanyeol  
|Luhan
|Reindeer Kyungsoo (current)
|}
|}


==Newbie==
==Newbie==
Line 40: Line 41:
| {{color|red|Town win, Day 3}}
| {{color|red|Town win, Day 3}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | My first game of forum mafia! Fumbled around a lot as I attempted to fake town play (without ever having played town before). Day 1 was cake - sitting back as an overly defense townie got himself lynched. We noticed Praetyre playing cautiously and killed him, thinking he was a PR (he was Cop!). My partner had plenty of experience from another site and looked super town to everyone until she made a HORRENDOUS slip and got lynched. Implosion was then able to PoE me. Even though it's my first game, I'm rather embarrassed by it because I kind of just rolled over once my lynch gained traction.
| colspan="7" | My first game of forum mafia. Faking town play is hard if you've never played town before. I fumbled a lot, but Day 1 was easy and a belligerent townie got themselves lynched. We noticed Praetyre playing cautiously and killed him, thinking he was a PR (he was Cop!). My partner had plenty of experience from another site and looked super town to everyone until she made a HORRENDOUS slip and got lynched. Implosion was then able to PoE me. Even though it's my first game, I'm rather embarrassed by it because I kind of just rolled over once my lynch gained traction. I wish I could reread it to see just how bad I was, but half the game was lost in the rollback.
|}
|}


Line 60: Line 61:
| {{color|green|Scum win, Day 3}}
| {{color|green|Scum win, Day 3}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | This game was an experiment in playing aggressively which is pretty far from my natural range of behavior. Notscience's odd newbie play generated a lot of confusing noise, so I tunneled him for two straight Days (till his lynch). I had a general strategy to either eliminate the most experienced players or get them on my side. We rolecopped the IC, The Acting Method, then killed him the next night (he was Cop!) before he could clear anyone. The final day I let Ms Marangal develop a confirmation bias towards DoctorPepper and mostly followed her lead. We convinced town to lynch during 6-P MYLO by saying a no-lynch would result in the same situation the next day, only with our town clear gone. I was pretty proud of my play this game since I managed to stay completely out of the line of fire, thought of as obvtownie. TAM said I was the scum MVP!
| colspan="7" | This was me "trying something new" as scum aka being aggressive and tunnel-y. Notscience's odd newbie play generated a lot of confusing noise, so I tunneled him for two straight Days. I had a general strategy to either eliminate the most experienced players or get them on my side. We rolecopped the IC, The Acting Method, then killed him the next night (he was Cop!) before he could clear anyone. The final day I let Ms Marangal develop a confirmation bias towards DoctorPepper and mostly followed her lead. We convinced town to lynch during 6-P MYLO by saying a no-lynch would result in the same situation the next day, only with our town clear gone. I was pretty proud of my play this game since I managed to stay completely out of the line of fire, thought of as obvtown.
|}
|}


Line 80: Line 81:
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 3}}
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 3}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | My first replacement game and the game that showed me I prefer town over scum by a mile. This game was severely disrupted by replacements (even the mod!) and I inherited a slot that, despite leading the lynch on scum Day 1, wasn't confirmed. It was a unique situation because all possible-scum players were replacements, unable to answer for their Day 1 actions. Our clears were zero help to discussion. At first people seemed to agree on a Sakura lynch, but then I got paranoid and started to see everything Ffery did through a scum lens, doing a lot of back-and-forth guesswork. When Sakura self-voted, Ffery thought me fencesitting scum too! Sakura could have nearly pulled off a lynch on me until she got tired of the day dragging on and self-hammered.  
| colspan="7" | My first replacement game and the game that showed me I prefer town alignment. This game was severely disrupted by replacements (even the mod) and I inherited a slot that, despite leading the lynch on scum Day 1, was a candidate for lynch. It was a unique situation because all possible-scum players were replacements, unable to answer for their Day 1 actions. Our clears were zero help to discussion. At first people seemed to agree on a Sakura lynch, but then I got paranoid of Ffery. When Sakura self-voted, Ffery got paranoid of me too! Sakura might have nearly pulled off a lynch on me until she got tired of the day dragging on and self-hammered.  
|}
|}


Line 100: Line 101:
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 5}}
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 5}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | Pretty interesting game. I rolled Cop and was getting read as transparent obvtown. At first this made me happy, until I realized I was basically making myself the Night 1 kill. I ended up investigating Xiao, and Mr. Flay, who I wanted to be able to cooperate with. Too bad I was killed before I could confirm my results - I was clueless as to how breadcrumbs work, and omitted them altogether. Kattaze was a pretty awesome Doctor who correctly chose to save me Night 1, but unfortunately he WIFOM'd and let me die Night 2; Night 3 he saved Xiao. He afforded town enough time to find scum, even after several bad mislynches. Scumteam started brilliantly - I didn't even start looking in the right direction till I was dead. I'm glad the right people, including my investigations, were around at endgame.
| colspan="7" | Pretty interesting game. I rolled Cop and was getting read as transparent obvtown. Not good for my first PR game. I ended up investigating Xiao, who bothered a lot of town, and Mr. Flay, who I wanted to be able to cooperate with. Too bad I was killed before I could confirm my results - I was clueless as to how breadcrumbs work, and omitted them altogether. Kattaze was a pretty awesome Doctor who correctly chose to save me Night 1, and Xiao Night 3. He afforded town enough time to find scum, even after several bad mislynches. Scumteam played a good game of coasting/not sticking out - I didn't even start looking in the right direction till I was dead. I'm glad the right people, including my investigations, were around at endgame.
|}
|}


Line 116: Line 117:
| Started
| Started
| {{color|green|Vanilla Townie}}
| {{color|green|Vanilla Townie}}
| [[TheIrishPope]], [[Rank]], [[Nachomamma8]], TheGreatOne, homertve, maverick_alpha
| [[TheIrishPope]], [[Rank]], [[Nachomamma8]], [[TheGreatOne]], [[homertve]], [[maverick_alpha]]
| {{color|red|Killed Night 4}}
| {{color|red|Killed Night 4}}
| {{color|red|Scum Win, Day 5}}
| {{color|red|Scum Win, Day 5}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |Lackluster performance from me. A late Tracker claim Day 1 caused us to no-lynch, and he died that night. I had difficulty scumhunting and spent most of my time trying to make my intentions seem open and genuine to other townies. I thought I could recognize town!Mara from a previous game, but didn't realize I was wrong until she was lynched. When she flipped scum, town looked to be having a comeback, but the next day went into a standstill due to inactivity. TGO was massively lurking but refusing to replace out, coming around occasionally only to proclaim how much he didn't care about the game (he was later modkilled for not playing to his wincon). I fatally determined Likeabauss as town due to his case on me which I thought "full of conviction". At MYLO, I started a quicklynch on TIP that really shouldn't have happened without analyzing the nightkill. Blah. Even thinking about my play makes me die a little inside.  
| colspan="7" |Bad game on my part. A late Tracker claim Day 1 caused us to no-lynch, and he died that night. I had difficulty scumhunting and spent most of my time trying to look townie. I thought I could recognize town!Mara from a previous game, but she flipped scum. Town looked to be having a comeback, but the next day went into a standstill due to inactivity. TGO was massively lurking but refusing to replace out, coming around occasionally only to proclaim how much he didn't care about the game (he was later modkilled for not playing to his wincon). I fatally determined Likeabauss as town due to his case on me which I thought "full of conviction". At MYLO, I started a quicklynch on TIP that really shouldn't have happened without analyzing the nightkill. Blah. Even thinking about my play makes me die a little inside.  


|}
|}
Line 141: Line 142:
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 4}}
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 4}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |Enjoyable game hosted by a great mod! Day 1 I spent a lot of time shouting back-and-forth with JasonWazza only to sort him town, and after that helped mislynch a newbie. Day 2 I got sidetracked on Baezu (whose reads ended up being almost 100% accurate). Notscience's replacement was a boon to town, breaking up Day 2 momentum for the better (similar to Newbie 1382). Guyett flailed and claimed Tracker, outing the true one. I didn't wise up till he flipped that I had been looking in the completely wrong direction, but the scumteam made some off-color kills that helped me PoE. I think my biggest mistake was refusing to rethink Kaze, my strongest town read from Day 1, who ended up being scum. I was quite impressed that this was his first game. In 3-P LYLO he and I crossvoted, and a confirmed Jason hammered for the win on Day 4.
| colspan="7" |Probably the Newbie I've enjoyed the most. Day 1 I spent a lot of time shouting back-and-forth with JasonWazza only to sort him town, and after that helped mislynch a newbie (oops). Day 2 I got totally sidetracked on Baezu (who ended up not only being town, but also almost 100% accurate with her reads). Notscience replacing in was a boon to town, breaking up Day 2 momentum for the better (similar to Newbie 1382). Guyett flailed and claimed Tracker, outing the true one. I didn't wise up till he flipped that I had been looking in the completely wrong direction, but the scumteam made some off-color kills that helped me PoE. I think my biggest mistake was not rethinking Kaze, my strongest town read from Day 1, who ended up being scum. I was quite impressed that this was his first game. In 3-P LYLO he and I crossvoted, and a confirmed Jason hammered for the win on Day 4.
|}
|}


Line 161: Line 162:
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 3}}
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 3}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |The whole town would have been kind of lost if not for an insistent IC. I thought TNE "too scum to be scum" since I'd seen him play idiosyncratically as town, and opted not to hammer him until the last second as a conciliatory vote. That ended up being alright! With TNE scum-flipped, it was relatively easy to sort EspeciallyTheLies and Hopkirk; I maintained a lot of paranoia about Guyett and Notscience especially due to his purported "new playstyle". We had mislynches to spare so I didn't feel too bad about Shane. Night 2 featured a no-kill despite our Tracker being outed, so it wasn't scumhunting at that point so much as it was determining who was inactive (or dumb enough to no-kill) during the Night phase. HiddenPower replaced out like clockwork, so we had our answer. Interestingly, he was my first suspect Day 1, though I talked myself out of it.
| colspan="7" |The whole game might have gone differently if not for an insistent IC. I thought TNE "too scum to be scum" since I'd seen him play idiosyncratically as town, and opted not to hammer him until the last second as a conciliatory vote. I maintained a lot of paranoia about Guyett and Notscience. After a no-kill Night 2, it wasn't scumhunting at that point so much as it was determining who was inactive during the Night phase.


|}
|}
Line 181: Line 182:
| Started
| Started
| {{color|red|John Cavil, Mafia Goon}}
| {{color|red|John Cavil, Mafia Goon}}
| buldermar
| [[buldermar]]
| {{color|red|Lynched Day 4}}
| {{color|red|Lynched Day 4}}
| {{color|red|Town Win, Day 4}}
| {{color|red|Town Win, Day 4}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | My first foray outside of the Newbie forum >> obviously I still have to learn the ropes. AngryPidgeon came up with a cool flavor setup! Overall I had a really difficult time faking my reads or pursuing leads on anybody, and I think I hid behind the "I'm a newbie" wall too often for it to feel genuine. I lurked a lot :(. Buldermar and I fell for Nero's fakecrumbing and nearly fell for Malakitten's too. I think our mistake was not killing obvtown Orcinus because he ended up being a Role Cop. I observed some great scum play from my partner and town play from the others. Buld told me early on to try to forget my wincon and not stress about micromanaging, advice which I've since tried to incorporate into my games.  
| colspan="7" | My first foray outside of the Newbie forum - humbling to say the least. AngryPidgeon came up with a cool flavor setup! Overall I had a really difficult time faking my reads or pursuing leads on anybody, and I think I hid behind the "I'm a newbie" wall too often for it to feel genuine. I lurked a lot :(. Buldermar and I fell for Nero's fakecrumbing and nearly fell for Malakitten's too. Our mistake was not killing obvtown Orcinus because he ended up being a Role Cop. I observed some great scum play from my partner and town play from the others. Buld told me early on to try to forget my wincon and not stress about micromanaging, advice which I've since tried to incorporate into my games.  
''***As a side note, this game caused me to watch all 4 seasons of BSG in about 2 weeks right before finals, so there's that LOL.***''
''***As a side note, this game caused me to watch all 4 seasons of BSG in about 2 weeks right before finals, so there's that LOL.***''
|}
|}
Line 201: Line 202:
| [[BBmolla]]
| [[BBmolla]]
| Started
| Started
| {{color|green|}}
| {{color|green|Town Seer}}
|  
| [[Bulbazak]], [[EspeciallyTheLies]], [[T-Bone]], [[The Purple Rose]], [[Lastsurvivor]], [[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]]
| {{color|red|}}
| {{color|red|Killed Night 1}}
| {{color|red|}}
| {{color|green|Town win, Day 4}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |
| colspan="7" |Interesting and hilarious setup. People found me very scummy early game, particularly after I joked about a cop investigating me. Somebody pointed this out as a "godfather tell" when really, I just had more knowledge of the setup because of my role. I began playing to one end: survival. At the end of Day 1, I, along with everyone else, counterclaimed Cop. Total clusterfuck which I'm sure the mod was laughing at. If I hadn't corrected my own claim to Seer I wouldn't have been nightkilled. I did manage to investigate one scum that first night though, and it felt good.
|}
|}


==Mini==
==Mini==
Line 224: Line 223:
! width="15%" | Outcome
! width="15%" | Outcome
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
| [[JasonWazza]]
| [[JasonWazza]]//[[Equinox]]
| Started
| Started
| {{color|green|}}
| {{color|green|Town Deputy (Cop Mason)}} with [[DrDoolittle]]
|
| [[bubbajack8]], [[Majiffy]], [[Amished]], [[DrDoolittle]], [[Titus]], [[The Rufflig]], [[JacobSavage]]
| {{color|red|}}
| {{color|green|Survived}}
| In Progress
| {{color|green|Town win, Day 7}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" | Jason is the worst mod ever.
| colspan="7" |This played out like an Epicmafia game, and not in a good way. I wish I could say I played a solid Cop game, but the abundance of tracking/investigation cards made scum hunting totally unnecessary anyways. Despite the high scum-to-town ratio, I don't think scum had much of a chance given the godlike PR abilities.
|}
|}


Line 273: Line 272:
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |
| colspan="7" |
There was major gamebreaking going on due to the mod not providing a sample Role PM in the opening post. Sad because I love Tales flavor :(
There was major gamebreaking going on due to the mod not providing a sample Role PM in the opening post. So sad! I hope I get to play a Tales-flavored game soon!
|}
 
{|class="wikitable" style="width:90%; margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;"
! colspan="7" | <h3 style="none">[http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=34431&p=5494132#p5494132 Mini 1525: Tales of the Abyss]</h3>
|- align="center"
! width="15%" | Mod
! width="15%" | Entry
! width="15%" | Role
! width="25%" | Team
! width="15%" | Status
! width="15%" | Outcome
|- align="center"
| [[Yulia Jue]] (Modding hydra of [[Cabd]] and [[Syryana]])
| Started
| {{color|green|Mieu, Town Cowardly JOAT (1-shot Hide, 1-shot Commute)}}
| [[Nachomamma8]], [[Tammy]], [[Deacon Blues]], [[ProHawk]], [[thefuzzylogic99]], [[Mykonian]], [[Kazekirimaru]], [[orcinus_the original]], [[MafiaSSK]]
| {{color|red|Lynched Day 2}}
| {{color|red|God-General win, Day 4}}
|-
| colspan="7" |Fantastic playerlist, and my reads ended up being pretty great too.  During a massclaim, I gambited to claim full Hider, claiming that I wanted scum to avoid targeting me long enough for me to PoE through hiding. What I really wanted to do was be forced to claim my actual role, refuse to claim my other 1-shots while suggesting they were powerful, and force scum to try to target me while I would commute. Clearly this didn't quite work out the way I wanted, and I was lynched. On the last day, Fuzzy voted for Nacho - '''who I had previously  cleared with my hider shot'''. This was a very frustrating loss to watch, particularly since Town (except for our VI) had pretty much had figured things out and it seemed like an obvious win.
|}
|}


Line 296: Line 315:
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 5}}
| {{color|green|Town Win, Day 5}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |Scum derping harder than town derping = victory. Game started out a nightmare when Wayne dayvigged during RVS (for a gambit that ended up not working). We vigged him so he basically wouldn't throw the game. Town played a pretty horribly at times but luckily, scum was even more horrible (screwing up fakeclaims, flailing when accused, disappearing from the game completely). TSO and Killerjester prevented town from going totally astray, in my opinion. DP was a great partner to have for a first hydra - with general ability and scumhunting methods in common, we found ourselves compromising well. Overall we ended up being right about 2/3 scum, but definitely could have pushed harder.
| colspan="7" |Started out a nightmare when Wayne dayvigged during RVS (for a gambit that ended up not working). We vigged him so he basically wouldn't throw the game. Town played a pretty horribly at times but luckily, scum was even more horrible (screwing up fakeclaims, flailing when accused, disappearing from the game completely). TSO and Killerjester prevented town from going totally astray, in my opinion. DP was a great partner to have for a first hydra - with general ability and scumhunting methods in common, we found ourselves compromising well. Overall we ended up being right about 2/3 scum, but definitely could have pushed harder.
|}
|}


Line 313: Line 332:
| [[The Acting Method]]
| [[The Acting Method]]
| Started
| Started
| {{color|green|}}
| {{color|green|Harried Technical Director (Town Doctor/Vigilante}}
|  
| [[MafiaSSK]], [[Mantisdreamz]], [[Penguin_alien]], [[RachMarie]], [[Psyche]], [[twicetherice]], [[Smudger]], [[Nachomamma8]], [[BROseidon]]
| {{color|red|}}
| {{color|green|Survived}}
| Ongoing
| {{color|green|Town win, Day 4}}
|-
|-
| colspan="7" |
| colspan="7" |This was a hard game to get into and could've been lost to apathy. Doc/Vig was an incredibly fun role with some Jekyll/Hyde-esque choices to make every night. I am still unsure how this game got approved, as town had so many informative roles that scum had to be very careful about their night actions. Nacho replaced in and came to the rescue with PoE towards the end (we were happy to sheep), though scum were very unhappy about the replacements.
|}
|}


Line 327: Line 346:
! colspan="7" | <h3 style="none">[http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=31636 Mini Normal 1501: We're On A Boat!]</h3>
! colspan="7" | <h3 style="none">[http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=31636 Mini Normal 1501: We're On A Boat!]</h3>
|- align="center"
|- align="center"
|}
! width="40%" | Town
! width="15%" | Mafia
! width="15%" | Serial Killer
! width="15%" | Status
! width="15%" | Outcome
|- align="center"
| [[Grimgroove]], [[notscience]], [[Yates]], [[fferyllt]], [[Albert B. Rampage]], [[CrashTextDummie]], [[Garmr]], [[LolWagons]], [[Peabody]], [[Brian Skies]]
| [[Plum]], [[Empire]]
| [[SpyreX]]
| {{color|green|Complete}}
| Serial Killer win Day 5
|-|}
 
 
 
 
{|class="wikitable" style="width:90%; margin-left: auto; margin-right: auto;"
! colspan="7" | <h3 style="none">[http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=35988 Mini Theme 1537: Attack on Titan]</h3>
|- align="center"
! width="45%" |Human Faction
! width="25%" |Titan Faction
! width="15%" | Status
! width="15%" | Outcome
|- align="center"
| [[Kazekirimaru]], [[Tammy]], [[Rancid Broderick Drake]], [[ActionDan]], [[Plum]], [[displaced]], [[Kagami]], [[pieguyn]], [[kthxbye]]
| [[mastin2]], [[Paschendale]], [[BROseidon]]
| {{color|green|Complete}}
| Human win Day 6
|-|}


[[Category:Scummers]]
[[Category:Scummers]]

Latest revision as of 02:44, 27 February 2014

22, California. I don't really have a handle on my playstyle and I find it can shift a lot with every game I play. Here's a wiki for your evil meta purposes anyway.


Avatars

Jessica.jpg Rapunzel.png Chen.png Chanyeol.png Luhan.png Kyungsoo reindeer.png
Jessica Rapunzel Chen Chanyeol Luhan Reindeer Kyungsoo (current)

Newbie

Newbie 1176 (Lost in crash)

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Crazy Started Mafia Rolecop Mattman/Fionnabhair Lynched, Day 3 Town win, Day 3
My first game of forum mafia. Faking town play is hard if you've never played town before. I fumbled a lot, but Day 1 was easy and a belligerent townie got themselves lynched. We noticed Praetyre playing cautiously and killed him, thinking he was a PR (he was Cop!). My partner had plenty of experience from another site and looked super town to everyone until she made a HORRENDOUS slip and got lynched. Implosion was then able to PoE me. Even though it's my first game, I'm rather embarrassed by it because I kind of just rolled over once my lynch gained traction. I wish I could reread it to see just how bad I was, but half the game was lost in the rollback.

Newbie 1354: Pirate Mafia

Modded by Entry Role Team Status Outcome
quadz08 Started Mafia Goon BebbZ/Diabolik Survived Scum win, Day 3
This was me "trying something new" as scum aka being aggressive and tunnel-y. Notscience's odd newbie play generated a lot of confusing noise, so I tunneled him for two straight Days. I had a general strategy to either eliminate the most experienced players or get them on my side. We rolecopped the IC, The Acting Method, then killed him the next night (he was Cop!) before he could clear anyone. The final day I let Ms Marangal develop a confirmation bias towards DoctorPepper and mostly followed her lead. We convinced town to lynch during 6-P MYLO by saying a no-lynch would result in the same situation the next day, only with our town clear gone. I was pretty proud of my play this game since I managed to stay completely out of the line of fire, thought of as obvtown.

Newbie 1379

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Messiah/Zaicon Replaced in Day 3 Vanilla Townie Antagon, fferyllt, goodmorning, Karnage, Saki, theslimer3 Survived Town Win, Day 3
My first replacement game and the game that showed me I prefer town alignment. This game was severely disrupted by replacements (even the mod) and I inherited a slot that, despite leading the lynch on scum Day 1, was a candidate for lynch. It was a unique situation because all possible-scum players were replacements, unable to answer for their Day 1 actions. Our clears were zero help to discussion. At first people seemed to agree on a Sakura lynch, but then I got paranoid of Ffery. When Sakura self-voted, Ffery got paranoid of me too! Sakura might have nearly pulled off a lynch on me until she got tired of the day dragging on and self-hammered.

Newbie 1382

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Zaicon Started Town Cop Mr. Flay, Kattaze, Mutleyddmc, notscience, rmpeacoc, Xiao Long Killed Night 2 Town Win, Day 5
Pretty interesting game. I rolled Cop and was getting read as transparent obvtown. Not good for my first PR game. I ended up investigating Xiao, who bothered a lot of town, and Mr. Flay, who I wanted to be able to cooperate with. Too bad I was killed before I could confirm my results - I was clueless as to how breadcrumbs work, and omitted them altogether. Kattaze was a pretty awesome Doctor who correctly chose to save me Night 1, and Xiao Night 3. He afforded town enough time to find scum, even after several bad mislynches. Scumteam played a good game of coasting/not sticking out - I didn't even start looking in the right direction till I was dead. I'm glad the right people, including my investigations, were around at endgame.

Newbie 1386: Junior Noir

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Maestro Started Vanilla Townie TheIrishPope, Rank, Nachomamma8, TheGreatOne, homertve, maverick_alpha Killed Night 4 Scum Win, Day 5
Bad game on my part. A late Tracker claim Day 1 caused us to no-lynch, and he died that night. I had difficulty scumhunting and spent most of my time trying to look townie. I thought I could recognize town!Mara from a previous game, but she flipped scum. Town looked to be having a comeback, but the next day went into a standstill due to inactivity. TGO was massively lurking but refusing to replace out, coming around occasionally only to proclaim how much he didn't care about the game (he was later modkilled for not playing to his wincon). I fatally determined Likeabauss as town due to his case on me which I thought "full of conviction". At MYLO, I started a quicklynch on TIP that really shouldn't have happened without analyzing the nightkill. Blah. Even thinking about my play makes me die a little inside.

Newbie 1398: Can You Spot The Scum?

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
yabbaguy Started Vanilla Townie JasonWazza, enomis, Siegfried, Wilma, T S O, notscience Survived Town Win, Day 4
Probably the Newbie I've enjoyed the most. Day 1 I spent a lot of time shouting back-and-forth with JasonWazza only to sort him town, and after that helped mislynch a newbie (oops). Day 2 I got totally sidetracked on Baezu (who ended up not only being town, but also almost 100% accurate with her reads). Notscience replacing in was a boon to town, breaking up Day 2 momentum for the better (similar to Newbie 1382). Guyett flailed and claimed Tracker, outing the true one. I didn't wise up till he flipped that I had been looking in the completely wrong direction, but the scumteam made some off-color kills that helped me PoE. I think my biggest mistake was not rethinking Kaze, my strongest town read from Day 1, who ended up being scum. I was quite impressed that this was his first game. In 3-P LYLO he and I crossvoted, and a confirmed Jason hammered for the win on Day 4.

Newbie 1434: Chocolate Mafia!

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Maestro Started Vanilla Townie notscience, EspeciallyTheLies, Guyett, Debonair Danny Pietro, Hopkirk, Shane Survived Town Win, Day 3
The whole game might have gone differently if not for an insistent IC. I thought TNE "too scum to be scum" since I'd seen him play idiosyncratically as town, and opted not to hammer him until the last second as a conciliatory vote. I maintained a lot of paranoia about Guyett and Notscience. After a no-kill Night 2, it wasn't scumhunting at that point so much as it was determining who was inactive during the Night phase.

Micro

Micro 152: Battlestar Galactica

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
AngryPidgeon Started John Cavil, Mafia Goon buldermar Lynched Day 4 Town Win, Day 4
My first foray outside of the Newbie forum - humbling to say the least. AngryPidgeon came up with a cool flavor setup! Overall I had a really difficult time faking my reads or pursuing leads on anybody, and I think I hid behind the "I'm a newbie" wall too often for it to feel genuine. I lurked a lot :(. Buldermar and I fell for Nero's fakecrumbing and nearly fell for Malakitten's too. Our mistake was not killing obvtown Orcinus because he ended up being a Role Cop. I observed some great scum play from my partner and town play from the others. Buld told me early on to try to forget my wincon and not stress about micromanaging, advice which I've since tried to incorporate into my games.

***As a side note, this game caused me to watch all 4 seasons of BSG in about 2 weeks right before finals, so there's that LOL.***

Micro 252: There Is No Doctor

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
BBmolla Started Town Seer Bulbazak, EspeciallyTheLies, T-Bone, The Purple Rose, Lastsurvivor, F-16_Fighting_Falcon Killed Night 1 Town win, Day 4
Interesting and hilarious setup. People found me very scummy early game, particularly after I joked about a cop investigating me. Somebody pointed this out as a "godfather tell" when really, I just had more knowledge of the setup because of my role. I began playing to one end: survival. At the end of Day 1, I, along with everyone else, counterclaimed Cop. Total clusterfuck which I'm sure the mod was laughing at. If I hadn't corrected my own claim to Seer I wouldn't have been nightkilled. I did manage to investigate one scum that first night though, and it felt good.

Mini

Mini 1477: BANG! Mafia

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
JasonWazza//Equinox Started Town Deputy (Cop Mason) with DrDoolittle bubbajack8, Majiffy, Amished, DrDoolittle, Titus, The Rufflig, JacobSavage Survived Town win, Day 7
This played out like an Epicmafia game, and not in a good way. I wish I could say I played a solid Cop game, but the abundance of tracking/investigation cards made scum hunting totally unnecessary anyways. Despite the high scum-to-town ratio, I don't think scum had much of a chance given the godlike PR abilities.

Mini 1487: SpyParty Mafia

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
xRECKONERx Started Yvonne Pennyweather, Partygoer ChannelDelibird, Untrod Tripod, Lady LambdaDelta, Generic, Majiffy, GuyInFreezer, qwints, Antihero Lynched Day 3 Scum win, Day 5

I barely played this game >> I lurked and got wagoned before I could develop reads/defend myself. Remaining town got really apathetic - and combined with the mod not leaving deadline reminders and scum strategically lurking, there was a no-lynch. ON LYLO!! Fails all around.

Mini 1508: Tales of uPick!

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Elize Lutus/feirei Started Tear Grants, Town Doctor Cabd, notscience, Sakura Hana, fferyllt, The Acting Method, borkjerfkin, Skullduggery, Hanasawa, ISO Survived Canceled due to mod error

There was major gamebreaking going on due to the mod not providing a sample Role PM in the opening post. So sad! I hope I get to play a Tales-flavored game soon!

Mini 1525: Tales of the Abyss

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Yulia Jue (Modding hydra of Cabd and Syryana) Started Mieu, Town Cowardly JOAT (1-shot Hide, 1-shot Commute) Nachomamma8, Tammy, Deacon Blues, ProHawk, thefuzzylogic99, Mykonian, Kazekirimaru, orcinus_the original, MafiaSSK Lynched Day 2 God-General win, Day 4
Fantastic playerlist, and my reads ended up being pretty great too. During a massclaim, I gambited to claim full Hider, claiming that I wanted scum to avoid targeting me long enough for me to PoE through hiding. What I really wanted to do was be forced to claim my actual role, refuse to claim my other 1-shots while suggesting they were powerful, and force scum to try to target me while I would commute. Clearly this didn't quite work out the way I wanted, and I was lynched. On the last day, Fuzzy voted for Nacho - who I had previously cleared with my hider shot. This was a very frustrating loss to watch, particularly since Town (except for our VI) had pretty much had figured things out and it seemed like an obvious win.

Hydras

Salt n Pepper (Hydra with DoctorPepper)

Mini 1475: War in the Middle East Mafia

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
Majiffy Started Egypt, Town Even-Night Vigilante Titus, Your Troubles Will Cease, Purpkin, T S O, killerjester, Amrun, waynegg, runnerman, Baezu Killed Night 3 Town Win, Day 5
Started out a nightmare when Wayne dayvigged during RVS (for a gambit that ended up not working). We vigged him so he basically wouldn't throw the game. Town played a pretty horribly at times but luckily, scum was even more horrible (screwing up fakeclaims, flailing when accused, disappearing from the game completely). TSO and Killerjester prevented town from going totally astray, in my opinion. DP was a great partner to have for a first hydra - with general ability and scumhunting methods in common, we found ourselves compromising well. Overall we ended up being right about 2/3 scum, but definitely could have pushed harder.


Alpazard (Hydra with Notscience)

Mini 1513: Theater Season Mafia

Mod Entry Role Team Status Outcome
The Acting Method Started Harried Technical Director (Town Doctor/Vigilante MafiaSSK, Mantisdreamz, Penguin_alien, RachMarie, Psyche, twicetherice, Smudger, Nachomamma8, BROseidon Survived Town win, Day 4
This was a hard game to get into and could've been lost to apathy. Doc/Vig was an incredibly fun role with some Jekyll/Hyde-esque choices to make every night. I am still unsure how this game got approved, as town had so many informative roles that scum had to be very careful about their night actions. Nacho replaced in and came to the rescue with PoE towards the end (we were happy to sheep), though scum were very unhappy about the replacements.

Modded Games

Mini Normal 1501: We're On A Boat!

Town Mafia Serial Killer Status Outcome
Grimgroove, notscience, Yates, fferyllt, Albert B. Rampage, CrashTextDummie, Garmr, LolWagons, Peabody, Brian Skies Plum, Empire SpyreX Complete Serial Killer win Day 5

Mini Theme 1537: Attack on Titan

Human Faction Titan Faction Status Outcome
Kazekirimaru, Tammy, Rancid Broderick Drake, ActionDan, Plum, displaced, Kagami, pieguyn, kthxbye mastin2, Paschendale, BROseidon Complete Human win Day 6
Retrieved from "http://wiki.mafiascum-staging.net/index.php?title=Pitoli&oldid=100388"