You are viewing the MafiaScum.net Wiki. To play the game, visit the forum.

HowardRoark/Notes: Difference between revisions

From MafiaWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(created for game notes)
 
(added Mini 1230)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:


== Mini 863 ==
== Mini 863 ==
I was spared the D3 lynch, but was [[Mod Kill|mod killed]] N3 because of a mod error which caused confusion of my role confirmation. This all came about because [[lobstermania]] had made the roles flavored and was later told to revert that. This allowed us to confirm two townies, but placed me in a position where I was questionable. See the following posts: {{plainlink|post|1907516|169}}, {{plainlink|post|1979776|708}}, {{plainlink|post|1980018|717}}, {{plainlink|post|1980192|722}}, {{plainlink|post|1980242|723}}, {{plainlink|post|1980267|724}}, and [http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12466&postdays=0&postorder=asc&&start=725 page 30].
Concerning balance: 3 goons versus 8 townies and 1 doc is not balanced.
 
Concerning flavor: Small flavor text is permitted in a Normal game, but should never lead to the situation we found ourselves in (thus the rules). The best way to handle the role PM change situation would have been to post the townie one in the thread.
 
Concerning the mod kill: I understand why it was done. I'm not certain as to how it would best be handled, but perhaps letting the lynch play out would have been cleaner.
 
Overall: You did well, lobstermania. You made hard decisions. You posted accurate and timely vote counts. You kept the game going. Lessons learned, head held high, get 'em next time . . .
 
== Newbie 867 ==
My first game as an IC.
 
== Mini 1230 ==
Concerning moderation:  The moderator was having real life issues.  There was no backup moderator.  Vote counts were sparse and often incorrect.
 
[[Category:ScummerSubpages]]

Latest revision as of 03:00, 19 October 2011

This is for game notes that I feel are necessary and/or nice to have.

Mini 863

Concerning balance: 3 goons versus 8 townies and 1 doc is not balanced.

Concerning flavor: Small flavor text is permitted in a Normal game, but should never lead to the situation we found ourselves in (thus the rules). The best way to handle the role PM change situation would have been to post the townie one in the thread.

Concerning the mod kill: I understand why it was done. I'm not certain as to how it would best be handled, but perhaps letting the lynch play out would have been cleaner.

Overall: You did well, lobstermania. You made hard decisions. You posted accurate and timely vote counts. You kept the game going. Lessons learned, head held high, get 'em next time . . .

Newbie 867

My first game as an IC.

Mini 1230

Concerning moderation: The moderator was having real life issues. There was no backup moderator. Vote counts were sparse and often incorrect.