You are viewing the MafiaScum.net Wiki. To play the game, visit the forum.
Flagbearer: Difference between revisions
(better wording) |
(term replacement (not quite complete, as there's a setup that might need renaming)) |
||
| (One intermediate revision by one other user not shown) | |||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
| Normal = No | | Normal = No | ||
| Introduction = A '''Flagbearer''' is a role that causes its faction to automatically lose the game | | Introduction = A '''Flagbearer''' is a role that causes its faction to automatically lose the game if [[elimination|eliminated]] via the Day vote. Typically, they are used to weaken the power of a scumteam in [[Open]] setups, or to clean up [[Cultist]]s after their leader has died. | ||
| Standard = When a Flagbearer is | | Standard = When a Flagbearer is voted out, every member of its faction dies along with them (typically ending the game, except in a [[multiball]] game). This death cannot be blocked or otherwise protected against (the only way for a member of the Flagbearer's faction to survive would be to block the Flagbearer's elimination itself using a role like [[Governor]]). This is a [[passive]] role, having no powers other than the [[negative utility]] effect upon death. | ||
Flagbearers have no special interaction with nightkills; for example, if a [[Vigilante]] or [[Vengeful|vengekill]] kills a Flagbearer, they will die but the rest of their faction will continue without them. | Flagbearers have no special interaction with nightkills; for example, if a [[Vigilante]] or [[Vengeful|vengekill]] kills a Flagbearer, they will die but the rest of their faction will continue without them. | ||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
Many setups may want to make a Flagbearer [[Bulletproof]], or otherwise make them immune to their own team's [[factional kill]], in order to prevent a team sacrificing their Flagbearer to avoid the instant-loss condition. | Many setups may want to make a Flagbearer [[Bulletproof]], or otherwise make them immune to their own team's [[factional kill]], in order to prevent a team sacrificing their Flagbearer to avoid the instant-loss condition. | ||
A Town Flagbearer that functioned as described would likely be considered a strong indication of [[bastard mod]]ding. However, the setup [[Lynchpin]] uses a variation; if a particular Town-aligned player is | A Town Flagbearer that functioned as described would likely be considered a strong indication of [[bastard mod]]ding. However, the setup [[Lynchpin]] uses a variation; if a particular Town-aligned player is eliminated via the Day vote, all ''scum'' die (as opposed to all town dying). Obviously, this only works when the townie in question is not [[self-aware]] (but the scum do know who it is). | ||
It is reasonable to use a Flagbearer along with schedule modifiers such as [[Day Specific]], thus changing the priorities of the scum from one day to the next. | It is reasonable to use a Flagbearer along with schedule modifiers such as [[Day Specific]], thus changing the priorities of the scum from one day to the next. | ||
If a moderator wants ''every'' member of a scumteam to cause the whole team to lose upon death, it would be more common to make them [[Lover]]s than Flagbearers (unless the effect needed to be specific to | If a moderator wants ''every'' member of a scumteam to cause the whole team to lose upon death, it would be more common to make them [[Lover]]s than Flagbearers (unless the effect needed to be specific to the Day vote). | ||
This role originated from the [[Vengeful Mafia]] setup, where it was known as a "Godfather" (for the lack of an official name at the time); however, [[Godfather]] is a well-known role with somewhat different functionality, so this name is discouraged. Sometimes you will see players refer to a Flagbearer as a "Vengeful-style Godfather" to clarify which version of the role is meant. | This role originated from the [[Vengeful Mafia]] setup, where it was known as a "Godfather" (for the lack of an official name at the time); however, [[Godfather]] is a well-known role with somewhat different functionality, so this name is discouraged. Sometimes you will see players refer to a Flagbearer as a "Vengeful-style Godfather" to clarify which version of the role is meant. | ||
| Use = Giving a scumteam a Flagbearer makes some of their members much more expendable than others, thus likely creating additional [[associative tell]]s. The town can more easily understand these if the presence of the Flagbearer is known; thus, it's usual to use a Flagbearer only in setups where town knows or can easily deduce that the scum are trying to protect someone in particular (either because the setup is [[Open]] or because the players can make deductions from a [[Cultist]] flip). The instant-loss condition is comparable to the [[White Flag]] mechanic, in that it makes it easier for town to close out a long game, but its asymmetrical nature will lead to asymmetrical play from the scumteam. | | Use = Giving a scumteam a Flagbearer makes some of their members much more expendable than others, thus likely creating additional [[associative tell]]s. The town can more easily understand these if the presence of the Flagbearer is known; thus, it's usual to use a Flagbearer only in setups where town knows or can easily deduce that the scum are trying to protect someone in particular (either because the setup is [[Open]] or because the players can make deductions from a [[Cultist]] flip). The instant-loss condition is comparable to the [[White Flag]] mechanic, in that it makes it easier for town to close out a long game, but its asymmetrical nature will lead to asymmetrical play from the scumteam. | ||
As a scum role with a very large negative utility, the Flagbearer often enables the scumteam to be larger than normal given the size of the setup. However, be aware that the larger the scumteam, the more control they will have over the | As a scum role with a very large negative utility, the Flagbearer often enables the scumteam to be larger than normal given the size of the setup. However, be aware that the larger the scumteam, the more control they will have over the Day vote, so the negative utility effect becomes weaker in setups with large scumteams. | ||
[[Cult Leader]]s are frequently made into Flagbearers to avoid situations in which Cultists are still active in the game but have very little chance to win, typically causing undesirable [[kingmaker]] situations or erratic play. | [[Cult Leader]]s are frequently made into Flagbearers to avoid situations in which Cultists are still active in the game but have very little chance to win, typically causing undesirable [[kingmaker]] situations or erratic play. | ||
| Advice = If your scumteam has a Flagbearer, you must | | Advice = If your scumteam has a Flagbearer, you must protect them from the Day vote at all costs. However, you probably don't want to make it ''look'' like you're trying to protect them, or town will likely figure out what's going on. If your Flagbearer comes under pressure, it may be a good idea to start a distraction by trying to start a wagon on someone unrelated (ideally not one of the players attacking the Flagbearer, as many townies will pick up on that). | ||
If the presence of a Flagbearer is unknown, they will likely benefit from [[bus]]sing one of their team-mates (as long as this can be done in a natural way); bussing typically helps out one specific member of the scumteam at a cost for the team as a whole, but this trade-off becomes a lot less dubious when it's a Flagbearer you're helping. If there is a known Flagbearer, though, town may well anticipate this strategy. | If the presence of a Flagbearer is unknown, they will likely benefit from [[bus]]sing one of their team-mates (as long as this can be done in a natural way); bussing typically helps out one specific member of the scumteam at a cost for the team as a whole, but this trade-off becomes a lot less dubious when it's a Flagbearer you're helping. If there is a known Flagbearer, though, town may well anticipate this strategy. | ||
If the Flagbearer is not Bulletproof, it may be worthwhile to nightkill the Flagbearer if they come under pressure, to prevent the instant-loss condition. | |||
| SampleModifier = Odd Day | | SampleModifier = Odd Day | ||
}} | }} | ||
Latest revision as of 23:42, 29 July 2020
|
A Flagbearer is a role that causes its faction to automatically lose the game if eliminated via the Day vote. Typically, they are used to weaken the power of a scumteam in Open setups, or to clean up Cultists after their leader has died.
Standard version
When a Flagbearer is voted out, every member of its faction dies along with them (typically ending the game, except in a multiball game). This death cannot be blocked or otherwise protected against (the only way for a member of the Flagbearer's faction to survive would be to block the Flagbearer's elimination itself using a role like Governor). This is a passive role, having no powers other than the negative utility effect upon death.
Flagbearers have no special interaction with nightkills; for example, if a Vigilante or vengekill kills a Flagbearer, they will die but the rest of their faction will continue without them.
Variations
Some Flagbearers may lose the game for their faction if they die via any means (including nightkills); this should be clearly explained in their Role PM. This variation is particularly common with Cult Leaders who are also Flagbearers (as a Cultist has little chance to win without their leader's help).
Many setups may want to make a Flagbearer Bulletproof, or otherwise make them immune to their own team's factional kill, in order to prevent a team sacrificing their Flagbearer to avoid the instant-loss condition.
A Town Flagbearer that functioned as described would likely be considered a strong indication of bastard modding. However, the setup Lynchpin uses a variation; if a particular Town-aligned player is eliminated via the Day vote, all scum die (as opposed to all town dying). Obviously, this only works when the townie in question is not self-aware (but the scum do know who it is).
It is reasonable to use a Flagbearer along with schedule modifiers such as Day Specific, thus changing the priorities of the scum from one day to the next.
If a moderator wants every member of a scumteam to cause the whole team to lose upon death, it would be more common to make them Lovers than Flagbearers (unless the effect needed to be specific to the Day vote).
This role originated from the Vengeful Mafia setup, where it was known as a "Godfather" (for the lack of an official name at the time); however, Godfather is a well-known role with somewhat different functionality, so this name is discouraged. Sometimes you will see players refer to a Flagbearer as a "Vengeful-style Godfather" to clarify which version of the role is meant.
Use & Balance
Giving a scumteam a Flagbearer makes some of their members much more expendable than others, thus likely creating additional associative tells. The town can more easily understand these if the presence of the Flagbearer is known; thus, it's usual to use a Flagbearer only in setups where town knows or can easily deduce that the scum are trying to protect someone in particular (either because the setup is Open or because the players can make deductions from a Cultist flip). The instant-loss condition is comparable to the White Flag mechanic, in that it makes it easier for town to close out a long game, but its asymmetrical nature will lead to asymmetrical play from the scumteam.
As a scum role with a very large negative utility, the Flagbearer often enables the scumteam to be larger than normal given the size of the setup. However, be aware that the larger the scumteam, the more control they will have over the Day vote, so the negative utility effect becomes weaker in setups with large scumteams.
Cult Leaders are frequently made into Flagbearers to avoid situations in which Cultists are still active in the game but have very little chance to win, typically causing undesirable kingmaker situations or erratic play.
Play Advice
If your scumteam has a Flagbearer, you must protect them from the Day vote at all costs. However, you probably don't want to make it look like you're trying to protect them, or town will likely figure out what's going on. If your Flagbearer comes under pressure, it may be a good idea to start a distraction by trying to start a wagon on someone unrelated (ideally not one of the players attacking the Flagbearer, as many townies will pick up on that).
If the presence of a Flagbearer is unknown, they will likely benefit from bussing one of their team-mates (as long as this can be done in a natural way); bussing typically helps out one specific member of the scumteam at a cost for the team as a whole, but this trade-off becomes a lot less dubious when it's a Flagbearer you're helping. If there is a known Flagbearer, though, town may well anticipate this strategy.
If the Flagbearer is not Bulletproof, it may be worthwhile to nightkill the Flagbearer if they come under pressure, to prevent the instant-loss condition.
Sample Role PMs
The standardized Role PM for "Flagbearer" describes the passive ability as follows:
- As an unmodified passive ability:
When you are eliminated via the Day vote, all members of your faction will die.(edit)
- As a passive ability with a modifier:
When you are eliminated via the Day vote the nth time OR on day n, all members of your faction will die.(edit)
Example (unmodified)
Welcome to game! You are a Mafia Flagbearer.
Your team-mates are names. You may talk to them here during night phases and confirmations only.When you are eliminated via the Day vote, all members of your faction will die.
You have the following active ability:
- Each Night, if no other member of your faction is performing this action, you may target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, that player will die.
You win if at least one mafia member is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).
Confirm by replying to this PM with a summary of your role.
Example (modified)
Welcome to game! You are a Mafia Odd Day Flagbearer.
Your team-mates are names. You may talk to them here during night phases and confirmations only.When you are eliminated via the Day vote on an odd-numbered day, all members of your faction will die.
You have the following active ability:
- Each Night, if no other member of your faction is performing this action, you may target a player. Assuming no interference with your action, that player will die.
You win if at least one mafia member is alive and all other players are dead (or if nothing can prevent the same).
Confirm by replying to this PM with a summary of your role.