Dethy/Example

The following is a transcript of a game using the Dethwing Classic setup. See also Dethy/Analysis.

[00:18] Tallyvision: Day breaks.. Talitha has been hacked to death.
[00:19] Dourgrim: Oh no!
[00:19] Dourgrim: *gasp*
[00:19] Otaku376: oh my
[00:19] Opoku13: Not Talitha!
[00:19] Dourgrim: Rock on.
[00:19] JEEP: ack
[00:19] Dourgrim: So, shall we reveal and plan or just sit tight and no-lynch for confirmation?
[00:19] Dourgrim: Ack?
[00:19] JEEP: reveal in alpha or reverse alph order?
[00:19] Opoku13: Well, from past dethys, we're probably better off revealing our results. Otherwise, we're going to lose some of them tomorrow.
[00:20] JEEP: or roll dice does /roll work here?
[00:20] JEEP: /roll
[00:20] * Tallyvision rolls
[00:20] Dourgrim: I say we let the middle of the alphabet choose the order... Opoku?
[00:20] Opoku13: And that's the question, how to reveal. I say random. We want to avoid having the scum go last, but without knowing who that is...
[00:20] Opoku13: Roll away, Jeep.
[00:20] Dourgrim: Um... we can't just use the alphabet why?
[00:21] JEEP: how roll?
[00:21] Otaku376: i don't think we can roll...
[00:21] Dourgrim: We can't... Opoku, alpha or reverse-alpha?
[00:21] Opoku13: Eh, I guess it doesn't matter. Let's just pick a starting position and go reverse-alpha.
[00:21] Dourgrim: "Choose, Daniel-san"
[00:22] Dourgrim: Fine... sketch, you're first.
[00:22] sketchwickbtf: jeep guilty
[00:22] Opoku13: Otaku?
[00:22] Otaku376: jeep innocent
[00:22] Opoku13: Well, I got Sketchwick innocent
[00:23] Opoku13: Jeep?
[00:23] JEEP: sketch not
[00:23] Opoku13: Dourgrim?
[00:23] Dourgrim: Opoku GUILTY
[00:23] Dourgrim: Um, JEEP, define "not"
[00:24] JEEP: not guilty
[00:24] Dourgrim: (And a hearty FoS for using a vague term)
[00:24] JEEP: sorry
[00:24] JEEP: Dourgrim is confirmed innocent
[00:24] Dourgrim: S'okay... I'll remember that.
[00:24] Opoku13: Oh? So two guilties, three innocents.
[00:24] Dourgrim: I am? Cool... how?
[00:24] JEEP: hang on, want to finish... ;)
[00:24] Tallyvision: brb coffee
[00:25] Dourgrim: OMG, you broke it already? Jesus.
[00:25] JEEP: only one...
[00:26] Dourgrim: So Opoku and JEEP got the same investigation results?
[00:26] Opoku13: Yes. Both innocent.
[00:26] Dourgrim: And sketch and Otaku got opposites...
[00:26] Opoku13: For sketchwick
[00:26] Opoku13: On Jeep, yes.
[00:26] Dourgrim: ... and I'm the only one who checked anyone else besides JEEP or sketch... heh.
[00:27] Opoku13: Now, one of the guilties (Dourgrim or sketchwick) is the paranoid cop.
[00:27] Dourgrim: (or the liar)
[00:27] Opoku13: No, no. The *other* one could be lying. But one of them is definitely paranoid. The paranoid has no reason to lie.
[00:28] Dourgrim: Right, OK, play with semantics... we said the same thing.
[00:28] JEEP: So I need to explain Dourgrim ro did someone else figure it out too?
[00:28] Opoku13: I'm working on it.
[00:28] Dourgrim: Please explain for me.
[00:28] Opoku13: Haven't come up with it yet.
[00:29] sketchwickbtf: I made a mess of my first chart
[00:29] Dourgrim: Teach us.
[00:29] Dourgrim: Hehehe sketch... me too.
[00:29] sketchwickbtf: could somone summarize results in one line?
[00:29] Dourgrim: Me: Opoku G, JEEP: sketch I, Opoku: sketch I, Otaku: JEEP I, sketch: JEEP G
[00:29] Dourgrim: How's that?
[00:30] Opoku13: Sketchwick: Jeep guilty, Otaku: Jeep innocent, Opoku: sketchwick innocent, Jeep: sketchwick innocent, Dourgrim: Opoku guilty
[00:30] sketchwickbtf: thx
[00:30] Dourgrim: Right, sorry, I reversed the order in which they happened.
[00:30] Opoku13: Whatever
[00:30] Dourgrim: Don't you "whatever" me, young man!
[00:31] sketchwickbtf: so we ready to no lynch or what?
[00:31] Dourgrim: I think we're waiting for JEEP to explain the confirm.
[00:31] Otaku376: i think i figured out how dour is innocent
[00:31] Opoku13: Um...? How did Jeep get that Dourgrim was a legitimate cop?
[00:32] Otaku376: if dour is scum, then sketch is paranoid, and one of otaku opoku or jeep is insane
[00:32] Otaku376: since no one investigated dour, no one can be insane
[00:32] Otaku376: therefore dour is legit?
[00:32] Opoku13: Neat.
[00:32] JEEP: sorry, got distracted
[00:32] Dourgrim: OK, yeah, that makes sense.
[00:32] Dourgrim: *about to die*
[00:32] JEEP: yep, that's it
[00:32] Otaku376: hey i figured something out!
[00:33] Opoku13: Is that all we have?
[00:33] JEEP: My money is on Otaku
[00:33] JEEP: So: tonight investigations should be:
[00:35] JEEP: Dourgrim investigate Otaku ;; Opoku investigate Dourgrim;; Otaku investigate Opoku ;; Sketchwick investigate Otaku ;; jeep investigate Otaku
[00:35] JEEP: IMO
[00:35] Dourgrim: Hang on, thinking...
[00:36] Dourgrim: Opoku is cleared too, isn't he?
[00:36] Opoku13: Ok, so I'm confirming if sketchwick is scum by calibrating...
[00:36] JEEP: how?
[00:36] Opoku13: Yes, he's right.
[00:36] Dourgrim: Well, if he's scum, then I'm sane, sketch is insane, leaves no paranoid...
[00:36] Otaku376: you could still be paranoid
[00:36] Dourgrim: NOW I finally get how to look at this game.
[00:37] Dourgrim: OK, you're right... damn.
[00:37] Dourgrim: I felt all smart and stuff there for a second.
[00:37] sketchwickbtf: I trust jeep
[00:37] JEEP: If Opoku is scum: then Dourgrim=paranoid, otaku sane or naive; sketchwick insane, jeep sane
[00:37] sketchwickbtf: ready to vote no lynch and follow plan
[00:37] Dourgrim: So do I... just wanted to take a shot at it.
[00:37] sketchwickbtf: :)
[00:37] Dourgrim: Sure, let's give it a go. I can always analyze further while I'm dead.
[00:37] Dourgrim: VOTE: N-L
[00:38] Otaku376: VOTE: NO LYNCH
[00:38] sketchwickbtf: vote: no lynch
[00:38] Opoku13: Dourgrim is either paranoid, insane, or sane, since he got a guilty result. If he's paranoid, I'm innocent. If he's insane, I'm innocent. If he's sane, then the math doesn't work out because someone else had to switch too to get the insane cop's innocent result. But nobody else investigated me...
[00:38] Opoku13: Ah, close but not quite.
[00:38] Opoku13: VOTE: NO LYNCH
[00:38] JEEP: VOTE: No lynch
[00:38] Tallyvision: Voting: NO LYNCH (everyone)
[00:38] Dourgrim: Wow, a unanimous vote... cool!
[00:38] Tallyvision: It is night, send choices.
[00:41] Tallyvision: Day breaks and Jeeps battered body is lying on the ground
[00:41] Opoku13: Well, that's interesting.
[00:41] Dourgrim: Heheheh... poor JEEP, he always dies in Dethy.
[00:41] Otaku376: heh
[00:42] Dourgrim: OK, since I'm confirmed, sound off in reverse-alpha.
[00:42] Opoku13: sketch?
[00:43] sketchwickbtf: Ot= guilty
[00:43] Opoku13: Otaku?
[00:43] Otaku376: opoku = innocent
[00:43] Opoku13: I got Dourgrim... *drum roll* ... guilty
[00:43] Opoku13: Dour?
[00:44] Dourgrim: Otaku = GUILTY
[00:44] Opoku13: Well, I found us our scum. It's sketchwick.
[00:44] Dourgrim: How do you figure?
[00:44] Dourgrim: Because you're automatically insane?
[00:45] Opoku13: Well, my result flipped. That means that either I am insane, or sane, and either Dourgrim's scum or sketchwick. Since we've eliminated Dourgrim being scum, it has to be sketch.
[00:45] *** Wacky Loon has joined the chat.
[00:45] Opoku13: wb Wacky
[00:45] Wacky Loon: ta
[00:45] Dourgrim: Or you're full of crap... there's always that possibility, too.
[00:45] Dourgrim: WB, Wacky.
[00:46] Otaku376: hmm...
[00:46] Opoku13: Well, yes. That's a possibility. But my changed result should fit in with everyone else's. Can we have a summary of the night one and night 2 results?
[00:46] Dourgrim: OK... I'm obviously either paranoid or insane...
[00:46] Otaku376: Jeep=I Opoku=I
[00:47] Otaku376: I am sane or naive
[00:47] Opoku13: Yes, that's a good format. sketch=I, Dour=G
[00:47] Dourgrim: No, Opoku, sketch can't be the scum.
[00:47] Otaku376: he could, it's just not confirmed
[00:47] Dourgrim: Wait, that's wrong... crap.
[00:48] Opoku13: Let's get the results up for everyone.
[00:48] Dourgrim: OP=I, OT=I
[00:48] Opoku13: Excuse me? I thought you got guilty results for me?
[00:48] Dourgrim: Oh, sorry, yeah, G's instead of I's.
[00:48] Dourgrim: My bad...
[00:49] Opoku13: Obviously we know they're really I's, because there's no way both of us could be guilty. Or you're paranoid.
[00:50] Opoku13: Jeep got sketch=I
[00:50] Otaku376: do we need another night to dissect this?
[00:50] Dourgrim: I think Otaku is cleared.
[00:50] Opoku13: sketch got...Jeep=G, Ot=G
[00:51] Dourgrim: Because if he was scum, then the results don't work.
[00:51] Dourgrim: both sketch and I can't both be paranoid, and we both got 2 G results.
[00:51] Opoku13: Right
[00:51] Opoku13: Although one of you could be lying.
[00:52] Dourgrim: Not if Otaku's the scum.
[00:52] Dourgrim: What'd be the point?
[00:52] Otaku376: cops have no reason to lie
[00:52] Opoku13: True. Sorry. It's late.
[00:52] Otaku376: i think we need another investigation....
[00:53] Opoku13: Well, we can afford one if we have to.
[00:53] Dourgrim: If Opoku is scum, then Otaku must be naive, I'm paranoid... no, that doesn't work either.
[00:53] Dourgrim: So therefore, VOTE: sketch
[00:53] Opoku13: VOTE: SKETCH
[00:53] sketchwickbtf: why?
[00:54] Dourgrim: OK... UNVOTE while I explain
[00:54] sketchwickbtf: FOS voters
[00:54] sketchwickbtf: we lynch wrong we lose
[00:54] Dourgrim: Oh hush, sketch.
[00:54] Dourgrim: ;-)
[00:54] Dourgrim: OK, here goes.
[00:54] Dourgrim: We know I'm legit, right?
[00:54] Opoku13: Right
[00:54] Dourgrim: OK...
[00:54] sketchwickbtf: jeep said so good enough for me
[00:55] Dourgrim: If Opoku is scum, then I must be paranoid, Otaku must be naive, which would make you also paranoid, sketch... so that's out.
[00:55] Opoku13: So the question is whether or not *I'm* legit, because my result flipped. If I'm legit, I'm insane and sketchwick is scum, from my investigation.
[00:55] sketchwickbtf: I could be insnae
[00:55] Dourgrim: If Otaku is scum, then I'm still paranoid (I think that's a given), but so are you because you gave two guilties as well.
[00:56] Dourgrim: Therefore, you're scum.
[00:56] Dourgrim: VOTE: sketch
[00:56] sketchwickbtf: what?
[00:56] sketchwickbtf: I could be the insane cop?
[00:56] Dourgrim: UNVOTE
[00:56] Dourgrim: How?
[00:56] Otaku376: because it works
[00:56] Opoku13: No, it doesn't.
[00:56] Dourgrim: If Opoku is scum, then you're insane, I'm paranoid, Otaku is naive, and JEEP was sane? Lemme work that out.
[00:57] Dourgrim: Yes, that's possible... my bad.
[00:57] Opoku13: Because if he's insane, I'm innocent because he got two guilty results. That means I'm really a cop, and my investigation *changed* from night to night. If I'm a real cop, and Dourgrim is innocent, sketchwick MUST be scum.
[00:57] sketchwickbtf: why?
[00:58] Dourgrim: But sketch didn't investigate you... so he could be insane with two guilties.
[00:58] Opoku13: Wait. Who did he investigate?
[00:58] Dourgrim: Otaku.
[00:58] Dourgrim: Right, sketch?
[00:58] Opoku13: Damn. Now *I'm* falling victim to the name similarity. :p
[00:58] Otaku376: heh
[00:59] Dourgrim: OK, so Otaku is cleared, that one I'm sure on.
[01:00] sketchwickbtf: it's between me and Op
[01:00] Dourgrim: Which means we need one more Night to calibrate.
[01:00] sketchwickbtf: need to investigate tonight
[01:00] Otaku376: i think we do need that last night
[01:00] Otaku376: but who to investigate?
[01:00] Opoku13: Right. And you have to clear me somehow, so my investigation stands up.
[01:01] Opoku13: Ok, what are the possibilities in terms of who is what cop?
[01:01] sketchwickbtf: well *I* know Op is scum, I can investigate him and get I because I'm insane cop
[01:01] sketchwickbtf: propaly jeep was sane and Op guessed at that
[01:01] sketchwickbtf: dour will get G no matter what
[01:01] Dourgrim: Ack...
[01:01] sketchwickbtf: and Ot will get I
[01:01] Dourgrim: I suck at this... hang on.
[01:01] Otaku376: I will investigate sketch, Sketch investigate opoku, dour investigate sketch, opoku otaku
[01:02] Opoku13: If Jeep was sane, are we going to get anywhere?
[01:02] sketchwickbtf: no
[01:02] sketchwickbtf: We might as well lynch you now
[01:02] Dourgrim: I investigate sketch tonight... so does Otaku... Opoku investigates Otaku, and sketch investigates me.
[01:02] sketchwickbtf: problem for me is Dour and Ot don't kow your scum  :(
[01:03] Opoku13: Same problem for me, really. Only I actually have a real result to back it up, useless as it seems now.
[01:03] Otaku376: VOTE: NO LYNCH
[01:03] Dourgrim: If Ot's result isn't guilty, he knows he's sane and can lynch... ditto for mine. One of us should be able to figure it out.
[01:03] sketchwickbtf: dours plan seems fine
[01:03] sketchwickbtf: vote no lynch
[01:03] Dourgrim: Ack... I"m not sure it's right, though..
[01:03] Opoku13: Sigh. UNVOTE: SKETCH, VOTE: NO LYNCH
[01:03] Opoku13: It's as good as anything.
[01:03] Dourgrim: crap... I hope it works.
[01:04] Dourgrim: (I also hope our Mod is still with us... hehe)
[01:04] Tallyvision: Voting: NO LYNCH (3)
[01:04] Opoku13: Yup, she is
[01:04] Tallyvision: It is now night
[01:04] Dourgrim: I guess so.
[01:05] Dourgrim: I am sooo going to bed after this game.
[01:05] Opoku13: No kidding
[01:05] Otaku376: yeah i was actually thinking of catching up on sleep tonite
[01:05] Otaku376: oh well...
[01:05] Opoku13: lol
[01:06] Tallyvision: Day time... You find little pieces of Otaku inside a paper bag
[01:06] sketchwickbtf: me first again?
[01:06] Opoku13: Sure, go
[01:07] sketchwickbtf: dour is guilt
[01:07] Opoku13: Otaku is guilty
[01:07] sketchwickbtf: you are all guilty! except OP but I haven't investigated him nor will get a chance  :(
[01:07] Opoku13: Dourgrim?
[01:08] Dourgrim: sketch is guilty
[01:08] Dourgrim: (surprise surprise)
[01:08] sketchwickbtf: nod
[01:08] Opoku13: Yeah, no surprises here. It's up to you, Dourgrim.
[01:08] Opoku13: VOTE: SKETCHWICK
[01:08] Dourgrim: OK, let me analyze.
[01:08] sketchwickbtf: well all I have in my effort to convince you Op is scum is that *I* did all my revelations first and he was really ready to quick lynch me yesterday
[01:08] sketchwickbtf: vote: Opoku
[01:09] Opoku13: Quick lynch? On a valid cop result?
[01:09] sketchwickbtf: LOL
[01:09] sketchwickbtf: valid scum result more like
[01:09] Otaku376: (yes! i am not caught in the endgame!)
[01:09] Opoku13: Well, if I got a valid result as a cop showing you were scum, should I therefore NOT be voting for you, by your logic?
[01:09] Tallyvision: Vote Count: Sketchwick (1) - Opoku, Opoku (1) - Sketchwick
[01:10] Tallyvision: 2 to lynch
[01:10] sketchwickbtf: take it from me, the true one getting valid results, in dethy your results mean nothing to town, only what everyone can prove
[01:10] Opoku13: Which is true. But I put my vote where my mouth was. You didn't yesterday.
[01:11] sketchwickbtf: nice move killing jeep even though dour was confirmed innocent, did you just guess he was sane?
[01:11] sketchwickbtf: do you have an alter ego on mafiascum?
[01:11] Opoku13: You think I'm that good? I'm impressed, but I don't deserve that much credit.
[01:11] Opoku13: <<-- Yaw
[01:12] sketchwickbtf: was that just an admission????
[01:12] Dourgrim: I'm going with a hunch, because no amount of analysis will narrow it down in my brain right now.
[01:12] sketchwickbtf: dear lord I just complimented him on killing jeep and he accept the compliment!
[01:12] Dourgrim: VOTE: sketch
[01:12] sketchwickbtf: fucker
[01:12] Opoku13: No, I actually turned the compliment down.
[01:12] Tallyvision: GAME OVER
[01:12] Tallyvision: COPS WIN!